Skip to main content
D.A.R
Legend
Apr 4, 2011 12:23 AM UTC
Open for Voting

P: Ability to name custom crops and have more than 5

I would like to be able to name custom crops in Lightroom. Saving them as ratios is great but one step further would be the ability to give them a relative name for certain projects or uses.Perhaps also not limit me to 5 custom ratios.

Image is not available

80 replies

Known Participant
Dec 21, 2012 1:49 PM UTC
Have you considered saving snapshot with these relative names?
Translate
areohbee
Legend
Dec 20, 2012 8:35 PM UTC
Consider XmpCrop - it's a bit klunky, but gets the job done.
Translate
Inspiring
Dec 20, 2012 8:26 AM UTC
Let's get this small but much needed feature into LR 4.4!

Or in LR5 early next year 🙂
Translate
Inspiring
Dec 19, 2012 9:15 PM UTC
we are still waiting for good custom crop settings in Lightroom, I know use Photo Mechanic to select my photo's en to crop them with pre -defined ( and saved!) aspect ratio's , after that I import them into Lightroom and th e crops are there as well ...
Translate
areohbee
Legend
Apr 20, 2012 9:53 PM UTC
The workaround for the time being, since croppage is not savable in presets either, is to maintain a set of images whose sole purpose in life is to house crop settings. Then when you want to apply a custom crop, just select the corresponding image, and copy it's settings to the clipboard, then paste on desired image(s). Klunky * kludgy, but in case it's better than nothing...

Bonus Idea:
=========
Somebody could write a plugin to assign crop "presets", e.g.:
1. save metadata
2. modify crop setting in xmp (exiftool can do this)
3. read metadata

Note: 1 & 3 are not supported by the current SDK (3.0) but can be done with a trick. And anyway this too is a kindy iffy way of doing it...

PS - I doubt I'll be writing such a plugin in the near future, unless Adobe adds better support to SDK(4).

Rob
Translate
Inspiring
Apr 20, 2012 9:30 PM UTC
i have been using Lightroom since it was first released. to be able to set as many custom crop presets as i want and name them on my terms (just like any other preset) has been my number one request for Lightroom. i have so many different outputs that it's more work to keep re-entering a specific crop ratio when i need it. especially since it's usually pixel-based, so i have to work out what the crop would be in inches. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make crop ratios an option for future releases!
Translate
Inspiring
Jan 31, 2012 1:01 PM UTC
It has always struck me as being odd that in all other dropdown menu's in LR you have the option to save it as a named preset. The Crop dropdown is the one strangely missing out on this functionality.

Please!
Translate
Inspiring
Jan 30, 2012 11:59 PM UTC
The case is clear and easy , simply the possibility to save numerous custom crop presets in Lightroom, that's what computers are for , remember simple number things , so we can use them quickly

Paul V.
Translate
Inspiring
Jan 15, 2012 9:11 PM UTC
Very much needed indeed. I have many clients that request different ratio's than the standard ones. To be able to save / edit those would a great timesaver!
Translate
Participant
Jan 12, 2012 10:01 PM UTC
I like this idea!

Maybe it would be possible to have the same mechanism for the crop ratios as with the metadata presets or filenaming presets, where one can add/modify/delete them!
Translate