Skip to main content
Participant
September 25, 2024
Open for Voting

P: Improvement to Transform Upright Tool on panoramas

  • September 25, 2024
  • 3 replies
  • 339 views

When doing panoramas of buildings, it tends to warp the building in a circular result. Similar to using a fish eye lens. The tools in the upright do not solve this problem. The guided tool really distorts the building even more. And when I am forced to take the picture from a low angle, there isn't a way to make it seem level. The best  I have found is that using Auto and then doing the vertical slider does a medicore job. 

3 replies

thomas_bredenfeld
Community Expert
Community Expert
September 29, 2024

you should https://ptgui.com give a shot. here you can play with many different projections and force vertical lines in the image to stay vertical. usually, this works better than the PS tools. especially this bending you describe which occurs when taking a panorama capture with a positive tilt angle and which can be very difficult to handle in PS, can be corrected with ptgui very precisely.

JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
September 29, 2024

This is because of the chosen projection in the panorama merge dialog. You will have to choose 'Perspective' to get straight lines, the other two projections create curved lines by definition, because they are projections inside a sphere or a cylinder. The Upright tools are not designed to correct that. Perspective projection is only possible for relatively small angles, however. If you cannot use it because the angle is too wide, then look at Photoshop's 'Adaptive Wide Angle' filter to correct a curved panorama. Or choose a dedicated panorama app like PTGui.

 

-- Johan W. Elzenga
GoldingD
Legend
September 25, 2024

Have you tested out if using a different projection helps, perhaps the Perspective.

 

https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-classic/help/panorama.html