Skip to main content
ralphlouzon
Inspiring
Oct 29, 2023 8:54 PM UTC
Open for Voting

P: "Intelligent" Grain, preserving Highlight zones

As you compare the grain effect beetwen Lightroom Classic and Silver Efex, you can see that SE is more natural, as the LR grain seems to be plastered on the entire image: the shadows and highlights are equaly recovered with grain while very bright zones shouldn't. It is very visible on B&W pictures.
On a picture if I add film grain effect, I use a Luminance mask and reduce the grain slider to reduce grain impact on the Highlights. Not bad but not quite satisfying.

I wish LR could implement a better film looking grain. Maybe a slider "preserve HL" could be added in the Grain panel, as it exists in the Vignette panel.

Hope this idea helps.

11 replies

Rikk Flohr-Retired
Adobe Employee
May 28, 2026 1:03 PM UTC
The following idea has been merged into this idea:

All the votes have been transferred into this idea.
Translate
Rikk Flohr: Adobe Photography Org
Participant
Sep 7, 2026 3:19 PM UTC

This link is dead Rikk. Are you able to reshare pls? 

Translate
ralphlouzon
Inspiring
Dec 27, 2023 6:25 PM UTC

Thank you for the insight, Color.io seems very cool and powerful. 

But I'd rather have a proper nice grain feature directly in Lightroom... 🙂

Translate
Community Expert
Dec 27, 2023 4:55 PM UTC

Awesome suggestion and you're right that the grain looks unnatural especially on highlights. 

Translate
Participant
Dec 27, 2023 3:55 PM UTC

@ralphlouzon 

I tried IO Color, the way the tool add grain is close to film

It lacks just a bit of "chunky" grain with a bit more detail in the outline shape 

Translate
Participant
Dec 27, 2023 3:54 PM UTC

Thanks big brain I'm trying to help by answering on LAPTOT ( in case you don't know how to read ) not to make irritating replies 🙂

I was adding an idea to LR mobile linked to the subject

Anyway 

Translate
ralphlouzon
Inspiring
Dec 27, 2023 2:38 PM UTC

Yes, I do the same, two or three lumisosity masks to differanciate the grain. But it is slower and I have to reconsider the lum masks from one picture to another.

In Photoshop, adding a pure grain layer in Overlay mode to the background picture gives better results than the grain tool in LRC. Adobe could do someting similar in Lightroom I guess...: choosing a grain type from a panel of grain, overlaying the effect in various ways, setting the opacity of the effect. A little bit of Photoshop in Lightroom and avoid creating a TIF or PSD file just for that.

Translate
Keith Reeder
Participating Frequently
Dec 25, 2023 12:17 PM UTC

"Lr Mobile"?

 

Wrong forum.

Translate
Participant
Dec 24, 2023 3:20 PM UTC

At this time, it's a functionality that I miss on LR mobile... I really hope someone at adobe will make this possible 

Translate
Participant
Dec 24, 2023 3:19 PM UTC

Hey

When I edit on laptop, I use a luminance mask to add grain only in shadows. I get very good results since a few weeks ( you can see my work on maxoufaitdesphotos on IG )

Translate
Participant
Nov 2, 2023 11:10 PM UTC

yeah the lightroom grain has bugged me since it's inception. I always do the same in photoshop and have 2 grain layers, one for highlights and one for shadows for that same reason. for how good lightroom is, it's crazy that the grain options are still so limited, leaving it look pretty bad if i'm being honest.

 

this is a great idea.

Translate