Skip to main content
johnrellis
Legend
December 1, 2022
Open for Voting

P: (Masking) Object masks should be computed on the cropped image

  • December 1, 2022
  • 0 replies
  • 122 views

Object masks should be computed on the cropped image, not the original image.  Adobe went through a similar learning process with Auto Tone, finally acknowledging that it should be computed on the cropped image:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-ideas/lightroom-auto-tone-analysis-should-apply-post-crop-scanned-photos-a-problem/idi-p/12249250

 

(But maybe this time it can be corrected in less than five years.)

 

Here's a use case (original image attached).  The original, auto-straightened and cropped image:

 

Dragging a rectangular Object-mask selection (faintly visible) around the original Polaroid image:

 

results in a bad mask:

 

Apparently, the AI algorithm gives more weight to the higher-contrast outer border edges in the cropped-out area of the photo than to the inner border edges within the crop.

 

Exporting the cropped photo and then making the same rectangular Object-mask selection gives perfect results: