Preserve original SDR JPEG rendition as the base of HDR gain-map exports
Please add an option to preserve a finished SDR JPEG as the SDR base when exporting an HDR JPEG with a gain map, while allowing the HDR rendition/highlights to be edited independently. This would be useful in both Lightroom and Lightroom Classic.
Workflow / steps to reproduce the reported issue:
1. Import an already edited SDR JPEG whose colors and tones are the desired final SDR appearance.
2. Enable HDR editing, without intentionally changing the desired SDR appearance.
3. Export a JPEG containing an HDR gain map.
4. Compare the exported file's SDR rendition with the original JPEG in the same color-managed viewing conditions, with HDR rendering disabled or unavailable.
Actual behavior reported: The exported SDR rendition can differ from the original in color, contrast, or highlights, even though changing the SDR appearance was not intended.
Expected behavior: An explicit preserve-SDR option should keep the original SDR appearance while the gain map provides the separately edited HDR enhancement. The user should not have to manually approximate the finished SDR image again using SDR rendition sliders.
Requested feature: “Preserve original SDR rendition / Use original SDR JPEG as base image.” Ideally, reuse the original SDR JPEG image data and color profile without re-rendering or recompressing it where technically possible. Alternatively, let users select a separate, aligned SDR image and HDR rendition at export and generate a gain map from that pair. These are alternative ways to provide the same independent SDR-base control.
This would let photographers add HDR highlights to finished SDR work while keeping a consistent SDR fallback for sharing and archival use.
This is a workflow/feature request based on the behavior described above, not a claim of a verified regression in a specific release. Exact application version, OS version, sample files, screenshots, and controlled reproduction measurements are not supplied. Please also clarify whether the current SDR re-rendering is expected behavior. Thank you.
