Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
December 19, 2017
Released

P: Please add smart albums

  • December 19, 2017
  • 91 replies
  • 9042 views

I would love to be able to create smart albums (aka smart collections) in the all-new Lightroom CC. Basically, a folder that contains a set of photos based on metadata information and updates automatically. The feature set should ideally contain all the options that exist in Lightroom Classic for smart collections. Thanks!

91 replies

Known Participant
January 8, 2021

Lightroom search 

Hi

Can someone explain to me how multiple search terms / filters work? 


It seems like multiple filters of a type are treated as OR where as filters of different types are AND.

Except for search terms which are always AND? 

This creates some unintuitive behaviour (IMO) 

So for example If I search for "Tree" "Car" I see pictures that match the intersection of Tree and Car (in any Sensi Keywords, tagged keywords, and I'll assume any other indexed fields) 

Okay, now if I Filter by location or locations what I get is results matching the following 

"Tree" && "Car" && ( Location: "India" || Location: "England") 

If I now filter by camera or cameras I get results matching the following

"Tree" && "Car" && ( Location: "India" || Location: "England") && ( Camera: "<camera a>" || Camera: "<camera b>")

This I can understand even though its counter intuitive, it does get odd when a search term (not a filter) is the name of a person / keyword.

So firstly have I understood correctly?

Now some more confusion, again an example

Person:A Person:B == Person:A || Person:B 

Where as "A" Person:B == Person:A && Person:B  (assuming A doesn't match other tags else be becomes (Person:A || keyword:A) && Person:B)

This means you can't search for Photos with 2 people in unless you use a Text Search and a Person Filter.

i.e "Mary" person:Bob results in and AND but Person:Mary Person:Bob results in an OR.

But if I use “Mary” “Bob” as a text search, I get nothing.

Both “Mary” and “Bob” will return results individually. 

So I am obviously missing some detail on how this does / doesn’t work.

Now you can do a 3 person Search using the following

Start in a person via the people view, (i.e. Mary)
Then search for “Bob” this gives you photos with Mary and Bob in, then filter by “Jane” and you only see Photos of Mary , Bob & Jane.

But 3 is your limit.

I ideally would like the ability to search for multiple people or other terms (but I could live with people to start) simply by writing a query.

I can do this with temp albums  but that shouldn’t be needed.
I’d really like a not operator as well.
i.e Mary & Jane but not Bob

Note this is possible in classic via a search or Smart collection (Oh I wish Lightroom had Smart Albums) 

Inspiring
November 6, 2020

Please bring "smart album" (or "saved search") to Lightroom CC.

This works great in Lightroom Classic.


I organize all my pictures with keywords and would like to be able to define albums/filters like ">=3 stars AND keywords contain hiking".

Inspiring
October 3, 2020

This is one of the most important features 

Participant
September 29, 2020

Please make Smart Album feature on Lightroom mobile.

Inspiring
May 23, 2020
I agree that Lightroom Classic's filter bar is too primitive. It needs more options such as the ones discussed here.
Inspiring
May 12, 2020
I think that Adobe will never implement this feature.
ronb4077550
Participant
April 22, 2020
No smart albums?  WHYYYYY?
Inspiring
February 28, 2020
I agree: smart folders is critical otherwise there's no real organization method since Lightroom doesn't use folders like Lightroom Classic does.

This is like a conscious product design decision: Adobe wants to keep some separation between Lightroom and Lightroom Classic, and keeping smart folders/collections in Lightroom Classic is one way. It's been years since this feature has been requested and it would be a very easy solution to implement, but Adobe has chosen not to.
Participant
January 5, 2020
Smart albums were my way of sorting my “work in progress” while it moves through my workflow. Would be great to get them back in the new CC.
Inspiring
July 13, 2019
That would be wonderful