Error 57 when trying to open a PDF

For one computer, I'm having intermittent issues viewing PDFs. It doesn't impact all PDFs, but when attempting to open certain ones I receive the following error:
- There was an error opening this document. There was a problem reading this document (57).

For troubleshooting, I've confirmed the following:

- The error appears for all users attempting to view the PDF on the specified machine.

- The error continues to appear after reinstalling Adobe Reader and running the Cleanup tool inbetween

- The PDF is able to be opened on other computers with Adobe Reader

- On the machine that generates the error, confirmed that no updates were available; the version listed is the same as the machines that are able to open the PDFs without the (57) error

- On the machines that are able to open the PDFs, there is a notice about signatures and IDs

Looking further into the Trusted Signatures and IDs, I attempted to follow the instructions at the following URL:

- Manage trusted identities, Adobe Acrobat

I run into further issues with the instructions above:

- When navigating to Edit > Preferences > Signatures > Identities & Trusted Certificates > More.. to review the settings, I receive an error stating, "Unknown error. Support Information: SecurityConsole-430

- When navigating to Edit > Preferences > Trust Manager > Automatic Adobe Approved Trust List (AATL) updates > Update Now, I select 'OK' to install the Trusted Certificates, but receive an error stating, "Updating security settings failed".

Any help getting the PDFs that generate the (57) error would be greatly appreciated.