Captivate 2019

I feel like there's a simple answer to this and I can't find it. 

I am using a smart shape as a button, in the properties I have it checked as a button, and am using Advanced Actions. 

One button gives me the option to check "infinite attempts", but another button I built the same way (I think), does not give me the option, and I can only select it one time.

What am I missing?

Thank you,

Carol