Apply appearance on a part of text

Hi,

I want to recreate a similar design to the one below.

Using type tool, I had seperated the club name and total by using the Tab feature. Then I made a copy of each line.

The problem here, since I have both (club name and total) on the same object. I can't change the appearance (as a result the Graphic style) of one without affecting the other.

Any tips or tricks that can solve this issue ?