Skip to main content
TomHolmes_G&I
Inspiring
November 21, 2018
Answered

Pathfinder intersect tool not working accurately

  • November 21, 2018
  • 1 reply
  • 6587 views

Never had this problem in years of using Illustrator, so assume it's another new bug.

If I draw one shape then another overlapping it, copy the rear item and paste-in-front, then select my duplicate and top shape – I should be able to hit the Intersect button and get a perfect shape of where the two items overlap. Instead I'm finding that this is no longer accurate, so I'm getting a slightly misaligned path, so the (pink) shape behind is showing through at the edges behind the front shape (blue).

Here's the result first at 'normal' size, and secondly when I zoom in. It's not even a consistent misalignment, is like it's just made a rough line that isn't the same. The match up is usually perfect, what's going on here?

    This topic has been closed for replies.
    Correct answer Monika Gause

    If I draw a circle and go to Object>Shape the options are Convert to Shape (grey out) and Expand Shape. If I expand the shape it still has the same problem when intersecting.

    I should add that doing intersects like this is part of my workflow for how I illustrate and I use this loads, it's not that I'm trying it for the first time or something. Never had this problem before, it's like something has changed and it's not 100% accurate since latest CC update. Straight lines seem to line up OK but on curves it's just that tiny but out that it leaves a load of messy edges when you zoom in.

    Have looked at view as GPU vs view as CPU and problem persists. I can view results in outline mode and the pats are not aligned along any curved edges.

    Would be good if someone could try replicating this in Illustrator CC 23.0.1 –

    • draw a circle

    • draw a square overlapping it in a different colour

    • copy the circle and paste-in-front

    • select circle and square

    • intersect

    • zoom in loads to check if curved edges are aligned


    Next thing you could check is the pathfinder settings.

    There is a setting for precision.

    1 reply

    Monika Gause
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    November 21, 2018

    The circle in the back is still a live shape?

    Try and convert it to a path.

    Object > Shape > convert to path.

    TomHolmes_G&I
    Inspiring
    November 21, 2018

    It's just a standard circle drawn with the Ellipse Tool.

    Monika Gause
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    November 21, 2018

    The ellipse tool draws live shapes.