Skip to main content
Inspiring
February 7, 2025
Question

Problem with Contentauthenticity and Illustrator

  • February 7, 2025
  • 1 reply
  • 475 views

Hello everyone,

 

An image agency has rejected my vector graphics on the grounds that I used the AI tools there. The problem is: these vector graphics consist of vector elements that I created in 2016. In other words: I did not use AI tools on these files. However, the stock photo agency wrote me the following:

 

“Thank you for your reply. 

According to the information provided by Adobe embedded in the file, an AI tool was used in the creation of the file. Please check your processes when creating the file to ensure you are not using AI tools. 

 

Now I have tried Adobe Content Authenticity and uploaded the two files there. And as a result, it shows me that I seem to have used Adobe Firefly when creating the file. Yet not a single element in this file was created with Adobe Firefly. So I asked myself why this is the case and where the error lies. I found out the following and I think this is something that can have serious consequences for us users:

 

If you have a vector element generated in Adobe Illustrator via Adobe Firefly, for example, but then delete this element again, this is noted for Content Authenticity. This means that even if the file has not been changed by an AI tool, this file is then saved as AI-changed!


The really stupid thing is that this prompt capability is displayed very prominently in the Adobe Illustrator interface, so you can never really rule out the possibility of clicking on it by mistake. If you click on it by mistake and then delete this AI-generated element, it's already too late. This file has therefore been specially marked for Content Authenticity.

 

I think this needs to be corrected urgently by the Adobe developers. I am happy to answer any further questions the developers of Content Authenticity may have! There must be a way to completely disable AI tools in Adobe Illustrator.

1 reply

Monika Gause
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 7, 2025

Exactly what did you do "by mistake"?

Even when you enter your prompt in the Contextual taskbar, Illustrator opens a giant dialog box for the generation. There aren't a lot of mistakes that can happen there.

 

Could you please describe steps by step what you did and in which version?

 

also: are there any designs in the Generated Variations panel?

Inspiring
February 7, 2025

Let's assume I'm working in lllustrator and go to the Properties field. Then click down and the Prompter menu is prominently displayed there. Now I accidentally click on an example figure and the AI creates this figure for me. I notice this and delete this figure. From my point of view, everything is done, there is no AI element in the file. However, if I save this file, it is displayed as AI-modified.

 

Following text in german:

Da ich weiß, dass du deutsch kannst, schreibe ich das auf Deutsch, da ich in Englisch nicht ganz sattelfest bin:

Nehmen wir mal an, ich arbeite im lllustrator und gehe auf das Feld Eigenschaften. Dann klicke runter und dort ist prominent das Prompter Menu dargestellt. Jetzt klicke ich aus Versehen auf irgendeine Beispielfigur drauf und mir wird mit der KI diese Figur erstellt. Ich bemerke das und lösche diese Figur. Somit ist es aus meiner Sicht alles erledigt, kein KI-Element ist in der Datei vorhanden. Speichere ich jedoch diese Datei ab, wird es als KI-verändert dargestellt.

Monika Gause
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 7, 2025

Das ist eine nicht aktualisierte 2024-Version, oder?

So funktioniert das nicht mehr. Es sieht so aus - kann man eigentlich nicht unabsichtlich benutzen:

https://youtu.be/Rvla6k9CYnw