Question

Generative Fill Feedback: Provide feedback for a chance to win free subscription time!

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
June 26, 2023
22 replies
6579 views

The Feedback Survery is now closed, thank you for sharing your feedback!

Winners will be notified.

Have you used the new Generative Fill feature in the Photoshop (beta) app?

If you have, we'd love to hear your feedback!

Please provide your feedback for a chance to win a free month of Creative Cloud all apps subscription!

👉 Take the survey!

Note: This survey will close on July 3rd at 12PM PT

This topic has been closed for replies.

Show previous replies

M

MarcinKrzyzaniak

Participating Frequently

As with some previous messages, Ai is too puritanical. What's wrong with this photo? This is a regular session for skincare products. I just wanted him to add a piece of grey background automatically, and I was treated like a criminal.

P

PMeesters

Inspiring

It doesn't seem to be related to skin exposure.
In my picture of a plant, the same thing happens
See post(https://community.adobe.com/t5/photoshop-beta-discussions/generative-fill-feedback-provide-feedback-for-a-chance-to-win-free-subscription-time/td-p/13894826)

M

MarcinKrzyzaniak

Participating Frequently

Maybe yes, maybe not. Who knows? I tried other similar backgrounds and only the one with the model was wrong. Let's put the problem like this: In your photo, I see a flower, You see a flower, probably most people see there a flower but Ai maybe see there an ugly slimy massacre which it treats as a bad thing. The problem, for now, is not that ai is stupid and can't recognize what is in the picture but the fact that there is no tool to report an AI bug (misrecognition of the photo) and the community guideline itself is lazily written and can mean anything. In another way, for example, you can't put a knife in the picture. Knives are bad, right? But what if one of your clients, is a restaurant and You just need a nice knife with sliced vegetables on a banner? Context is the key.

Rafaelis

Inspiring

It's pretty amazing. However the resolution is too low and it's often impossible to use due to user guideline false flags. See example below.

C

CaterinaRouge

Participant

I started my test plan (photography plan) but unfortunately the Generative Fill function does not appear. Can someone help me?

N

Nuttaphon308490198ldh

Participant

Hi,

Now PS beta can't use Generate fill tool. Want to know why?

Bakhtiar Uddin

Participating Frequently

Excellent performance of the generative fill option.

Trevor.Dennis

Community Expert

I was half expecting that the 'bad word' control built into Gen Fill would disallow 'Blood Stain', but it served up two sensationally good examples and one OK one. I am finding Gen Fill a huge time saver with the sort of composites we make in SFTW threads, and I am routinely using it constantly and barely thinking about it.

What is not so good is that the Beta version is proving to be very flaky on my fairly new i9-13900K RTX4080 system, and I suspect that the most recent update is worse than the previous version. I have mentioned disappearing icons from the Adjustments panel, but today I have experienced erratic behaviour with multiple selection tools with the martching ants dancing around the screen baring no relation to the cursor position. This was from the first touch down with the Lassoo tool, for instance, and I can repeat it at will. Restarting PS cleared it.

I have also been seeing that thing where you touch down with the Brush cursor, and a stroke darts across the screen from a random position. That is not so repeatable, and also seems to be clear after restarting. I am running with Native Canvas Deactivated.

[Images against guidelines removed by moderator]

P

PMeesters

Inspiring

How can the regenerative fill in the bottom part of this plant violate the guidelines ? And if it does, how is that my fault ?

The plant in question is Liparis loeselii (Yellow widelip orchid).

when I cropped it 16x9 I needed to add some content at the bottom... Photoshop says No!

C

Ctomeyphotography

Participant

I am also having this issue. Im trying to remove dried snot on a young client and everytime i try to select a very small area and let it do its own thing(no imput at all from me) I get a guidelines violation error.... The app is selecting the fill how is it a guidelines violation?

KarthikPollachi

Participating Frequently

generative fill option work very well.

J

Jean-Baptiste30818533dr6p

Participant

Hello,

Generative fill hasn't work so far for me since I installed Beta. 98% of request ("add a spaceship in the sky" "change the color...") result in an message of error saying that I infringe the rules... Very disappointing.

Best

F

Flotantte

Participant

same here! everytime I try to create somethig it says "generated images have been removed because they violate user guidelines". It does not matter if it is a composition, an element or any type of content, a fish, a plant in a house... whatever. I can't generate anything. Has anyone with the same problem been able to fix it?

M

Milan26428459d09i

Participant

Milan26428459d09i

Dobrý den.
Jsem vaším klientem.
Rád bych používal všechny funkce Photoshop Beta
převážně generativní výplň, ale mám problém.
Program uvádí, že nástroj je dostupný až od 18 let a to prý mi není..
Nevím, jak jste na to přišli?
Je mi 44 let.
byl bych moc rád, kdybych mohl za své peníze dostat vše co ostatní plnoletí..
Děkuji a s pozdravem Milan Roubal.