Skip to main content
Participant
November 9, 2024
Question

Clipping An Adjustment Layer To A Group Affects Blending Modes and “Blend If” Settings Within Group

  • November 9, 2024
  • 1 reply
  • 453 views

Description of the problem: I'm having trouble clipping an adjustment layer to a group in Photoshop without disrupting the Blending Modes or Blend If settings that are applied to the three layers within that group. Here’s a summary of my layer structure: 

Layer Setup:

  1. Vibrance Adjustment Layer (clipped to the “Design Group”)
  2. Design Group (Set to Pass Through)
    • 1st Layer: Screen Blending Mode + Various Blend If slider settings
    • 2nd Layer: Multiply Blending Mode + Various Blend If slider settings
    • 3rd Layer Multiply Blending Mode + Various Blend If slider settings
  3. Background Layer (T-shirt)

    Issue:
    When I clip the Vibrance adjustment layer to the “Design Group,” the Blending Mode/Blend If settings within the group no longer interact with the background layer as expected. It’s as if the Blending Modes + Blend If sliders aren’t applied at all.

    Troubleshooting Attempts:

    • Changing the group’s blending mode to Normal results in a similar loss of Blending Modes/Blend If effects.
    • Placing the Vibrance adjustment layer inside the group still affects all layers below, including the background layer
    • Converting the group to a Smart Object flattens it, removing the Blending Modes/Blend If effects relative to the background.
    • Merging any layers of the group without the background layer causes all belnding options to be removed.

    Goal:
    I need to clip the Vibrance adjustment layer to the “Design Group” only, while preserving the Blending Modes/Blend If interaction with the background layer. I have attached "Before Trying To Clip" and "After trying to Clip" images to further illustrate my problem.

    Any guidance or workarounds would be greatly appreciated!

    Thank you!

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

Sameer K
Community Manager
Community Manager
November 11, 2024

Hey, @Jesse35910355zjus. Welcome to the Photoshop Community. 

 

I think the issue you've described is an extension of the issue that is reported here in detail with a video: https://community.adobe.com/t5/photoshop-ecosystem-bugs/blend-if-stops-working-when-there-is-a-clipped-layer-on-the-group/idi-p/14958027

 

If it is partly related to and true to what you've posted, I'll merge your post into the parent thread.

 

Thanks!

Sameer K

(Use '@mention' to tag me when you reply)

Ged_Traynor
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 11, 2024

@Sameer K the link you posted is not working

 

Sameer K
Community Manager
Community Manager
November 11, 2024

Thanks, @Ged_Traynor. I've updated the link to the right post.