Skip to main content
Alex_R84
Inspiring
May 24, 2023
Answered

Free Transform Controls at Distance

  • May 24, 2023
  • 2 replies
  • 492 views

Hello,

 

I was wondering if anyone had a script or if there was a feature so that when you transform, the control handles didnt vanish when you move your cursor away from the object.

 

In older photoshop the control range was to the screen edge, allowing more precise control of rotation etc.

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Conrad_C

If you’re talking about how the pointer changes from the rotation arrows to the normal pointer when it’s hovered farther away, if no one comes up with the solution you want, this is at least some possible explanation/workaround for it.

 

One reason they limited the rotation-sensitive area was that when the pointer was in rotation mode all the way to the edge of the screen, it made it more difficult to do things like exiting Free Transform mode by clicking away. Sure, there are other ways to exit Free Transform mode (keyboard shortcuts or the option bar Cancel/Commit buttons), but a lot of people like to select and deselect using the mouse. If the rotation-sensitive area goes to the edge of the screen, there is no place to click to exit the mode.

 

Also, you do not lose precision with this change. As with many rotation features in many other applications, what you can do is begin dragging within the rotation-sensitive area, then continue your rotation drag farther away from the center. Photoshop will maintain that rotation drag, and will not drop it, as long as you keep the mouse button down while you are rotating. The only thing you miss is being able to start the drag further out, but there is nothing stopping you from starting the drag close in and finishing the drag farther out with just as much precise control as you had before.

 

So now we have the best of both worlds. It is now possible to click to exit Free Transform, and no precision was lost thanks to being able to continue the rotation drag as far out as you want.

2 replies

Jeff Arola
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 14, 2023

You can turn off that feature with the Disable Click To Commit saved to the

PSUserConfig file as explained here:

https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/kb/enable-optional-extensions-photoshop-cc.html#disable_click_to_commit

Conrad_C
Community Expert
Conrad_CCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
May 24, 2023

If you’re talking about how the pointer changes from the rotation arrows to the normal pointer when it’s hovered farther away, if no one comes up with the solution you want, this is at least some possible explanation/workaround for it.

 

One reason they limited the rotation-sensitive area was that when the pointer was in rotation mode all the way to the edge of the screen, it made it more difficult to do things like exiting Free Transform mode by clicking away. Sure, there are other ways to exit Free Transform mode (keyboard shortcuts or the option bar Cancel/Commit buttons), but a lot of people like to select and deselect using the mouse. If the rotation-sensitive area goes to the edge of the screen, there is no place to click to exit the mode.

 

Also, you do not lose precision with this change. As with many rotation features in many other applications, what you can do is begin dragging within the rotation-sensitive area, then continue your rotation drag farther away from the center. Photoshop will maintain that rotation drag, and will not drop it, as long as you keep the mouse button down while you are rotating. The only thing you miss is being able to start the drag further out, but there is nothing stopping you from starting the drag close in and finishing the drag farther out with just as much precise control as you had before.

 

So now we have the best of both worlds. It is now possible to click to exit Free Transform, and no precision was lost thanks to being able to continue the rotation drag as far out as you want.

dean.p
Inspiring
June 14, 2023

Hi, I would second the ability to at least have a setting where you could adjust this "active area," or use a "Legacy free-transform," or even a deselect hot-key... (feature request)

 

I've used Photoshop since the 90s, and this is undoubtedly now the top most anoying apsect of Photoshop for me. I do a lot of compositing, and I am continually frustrated with the free-trasnform deselecting, then (unless I'm transforming a smart object so no image quality loss), having to undo whatever transform I did, re-select free-transform and try again, but this time, paying very close attention to where my cursor is.... It's like, playing ice-hockey, but looking down at your skates to make sure the'yre the right angle. Especially as the active region does not scale with the zoom factor, it's the same screen disctance no matter what the zoom, which messes with your head..... often when you're transforming, you're zooming in and out, I'm constantly descelecting by mistake.

 

It used to be so second nature, you didn't have to think about it, yeah, it was a little pain there was no deselect, but it pales in comparison to the hassle now.

 

It's interesting, that the free-transform tools in Idesign, and Illustrator do not have limited active areas like it now does in Photoshop.