Generative fill breaching selection edges.

I really can't see that it has exceeded your selection by as much as a pixel. It has just blended the new content seamlessly with the unselected area.

Of course that looks artificial and weird, since there is no longer a horizon.

Which illustrates the whole problem with AI. It has no real "understanding" of image content. And you have absolutely no control over the outcome. That's not Photoshop; that's AI.

If you wanted a new sky, it would be easier to do with the traditional tools, not to mention easier to control. It shouldn't be difficult to make a good mask for the original sky.

Hey @san2see, is that photo from a music festival? It looks like it could be EDC, but I see snow in the background, and EDC is usually in the summer.

 

Also, could you let me know which version of Photoshop you're using? And would you be okay with sharing a sample image?

^CM

By @CMass

Thanks for your response. I'm using the latest version. My main question here is whether or not this is a common feature of generative fill. Samples? I already provided samples.