Skip to main content
Known Participant
September 16, 2017
Respondido

Shift + C does nt crop a perfect square???

  • September 16, 2017
  • 2 respostas
  • 1606 Visualizações

Just came across this problem. Ihave been using shift +c for years for cropping perfect square.....

And few days ago it does not work, it crops a square but it is not perfect...I get like 1840 px x 1798 px...

Why is this happening, is there a setting I need to check

So my only option is to resize the whole canvas to perfect square.....

    Este tópico foi fechado para respostas.
    Melhor resposta por JJMack

    Wait Shift+C  is a shortcut. Every time you use it it should select the next tool in in the tool bar in the group that the crop tool is in. So Sift+C might not select the crop tool.

    The Shift key is a Photoshop modifier key it is known as the constrain key.  How it works depends on many things. On when and when it is use. Shift modifies some shortcuts.  Use in the transform dialog bounding box with control points when you drag on a corner control point the transform will be constrained to the current Aspect ratio.  When use with a rectangle tool the rectangle  will constrain the rectangle to a square. with an ellipse tool the ellipse to a circle.

    The crop tool is a powerful and strange beast and has different modes of operation. Classic and new. It can be set to a fixed aspect aspect ratio like 1:1.  It can work  freeform where you can drag out any aspect ratio and in that mode if you use shift  the aspect ratio will be constrained to 1:1 square.  The Crop tool can also resample the cropped area.  As powerful as it is I do not use it  I prefer to use the rectangle marquee tool and image prop to keep things simple for my little mind.

    The crop tool does now work the same way in all versions of Photoshop. I do not use the crop tool.

    2 Respostas

    JJMack
    Community Expert
    JJMackCommunity ExpertResposta
    Community Expert
    September 17, 2017

    Wait Shift+C  is a shortcut. Every time you use it it should select the next tool in in the tool bar in the group that the crop tool is in. So Sift+C might not select the crop tool.

    The Shift key is a Photoshop modifier key it is known as the constrain key.  How it works depends on many things. On when and when it is use. Shift modifies some shortcuts.  Use in the transform dialog bounding box with control points when you drag on a corner control point the transform will be constrained to the current Aspect ratio.  When use with a rectangle tool the rectangle  will constrain the rectangle to a square. with an ellipse tool the ellipse to a circle.

    The crop tool is a powerful and strange beast and has different modes of operation. Classic and new. It can be set to a fixed aspect aspect ratio like 1:1.  It can work  freeform where you can drag out any aspect ratio and in that mode if you use shift  the aspect ratio will be constrained to 1:1 square.  The Crop tool can also resample the cropped area.  As powerful as it is I do not use it  I prefer to use the rectangle marquee tool and image prop to keep things simple for my little mind.

    The crop tool does now work the same way in all versions of Photoshop. I do not use the crop tool.

    JJMack
    Known Participant
    September 17, 2017

    yes stupid from me.....it is just C to select crop and than pressing only shirt to crop perfect square......

    I do it subconcious now...I did not even know I was not holding the C down.....

    But I guess I did not have the setting 1:1 selected......so now I think it will work perfectly, thank you, I set it to 1:1

    Trevor.Dennis
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    September 17, 2017

    A wee follow on from what JJ said.  I can personally think of no good reason to use the Shift key to toggle a Tool shortcut group, and I have been turning off that option in Preferences for some years now.  It means I only need a single finger on one hand, which feels like a a much slicker and faster process.  Since we have had the editable toolbar it is now easy to turn off shortcuts for tools you rarely use, but this is something I have been doing for as long as I can remember.  I can still remember wondering why the brush was acting strangely only to find I'd selected the pencil because the brush was already selected when I hit the shortcut.

    Semaphoric
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    September 16, 2017

    Are you using a Mac or Windows, and are you using a Wacom tablet?

    Known Participant
    September 16, 2017

    I use win 10, photochop 2017