Font in title and in text add in show same pixels, but a significantly different in size

Hi all. I am stumped. I have created a video with text on the various stock clips in the video. Some were inserted using a couple of Title templates provided in Premiere Rush. For others I used the 'add text' feature to add it, then chose the same font, style and pixel size.  However, even though all text was set at 131 pixels the text size varies greatly. I have tried going back in to reset the pixels, but that has no effect.

Has anyone else had this issue? What's the fix? How can I get consistent font throughout the video if I cannot rely on the pixel number to do so? 

Thanks for any knowledge/ assistance you can provide. 
Eli P