Skip to main content
Inspiring
March 22, 2017
Question

Problems with frame-by-frame viewing of videos

  • March 22, 2017
  • 1 reply
  • 1041 views

Whenever I attempt to provide frame-by-frame viewing of embedded videos in the new non-legacy H264 format supported by Adobe Acrobat, I find it does not work.

Has anyone else had this problem? Does it have a solution?

Or am I simply mistaken in thinking that it SHOULD work?

Specifically, what I would like is for there to be a key that one could press to cause the video to advance a single frame at a time. This works beautifully in Quicktime, where one can press the arrow keys to move forward and backward a single frame at a time - a function absolutely crucial for my videos, what are snippets of deaf sign language lasting about 2 seconds each, to be analyzed in detail by linguists who will read my PDF book. But the latest versions of Acrobat Reader block MOV files, and provide the capability to permit them only after getting past a frightening message that may as well have included a picture of a skull and cross bones beside it - a warning I cannot expect many of my readers to dare to contravene.

The closest thing I find to what I need in Acrobat's built-in video interface is the Seek function that one can specify in the Controls tab. But when I request this for my videos, I find that even this does not seem to work. Apparently one is supposed to be able to drag the little cursor along the bottom of the video to play it frame by frame, but when I try this nothing happens. Or maybe one should be able to click in various places and see the picture jump to that point. Both of these functions work beautifully in Quicktime, in addition to the arrow keys.

Actually the cursor does work slightly but it's far too crude. If I click it far enough over into the video clip - a full second, say - then the video picture does jump to that point. But what I need is frame-by-frame viewing.

Any suggestions?

Thanks for your help.

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

Joel Geraci
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 22, 2017

The built in video player for Acrobat doesn't support frame-by-frame advance via the scrubber. You'll need to have a custom player written for you. However, I recommend that instead of embedding the video on the page, you attach the video as a file allowing the native OS player to play the video. You can still put an image of the video on the page and place a button over it to open and play the attachment.    

PeytonTAuthor
Inspiring
March 23, 2017

I simply don't have the funds to have a custom player written for me, and even if I did, I would not be surprised to find the same block Adobe imposes in the way of Quicktime. As to the button solution, I am in fact using that to get away from Adobe's audio interface, but when I try the same solution for Quicktime videos, I'm warned about it by Acrobat Reader for every single video one at a time (my PDFs have hundreds of videos in them).

So for now I may be stuck with putting the videos in a separate folder that readers would have to go to - which would be a great detriment to their workflow, in my opinion.

That is, unless there could be some hope that Adobe would 'fix' what I consider a grave shortcoming. I hope they would agree that the functionality I describe would be a great thing to have.

Meanwhile, I hope you don't mind me asking: What is the purpose of this scrubber anyway if it's not to provide the functionality I describe? Is it merely that this scrubber in more coarse-grained, and works only in one-second increments instead of one frame at a time? What does this particular implementation of the scrubber accomplish that anyone would want?

(These are sincere questions. I'm not trying to be argumentative.)

Thanks,

Peyton

Joel Geraci
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 23, 2017

Selecting "Trust this document always" doesn't stop the warnings?

J-