Skip to main content
Brian Stoppee
Inspiring
August 3, 2018
Question

What Can Technology Make Better and What Can It Not Replace?

  • August 3, 2018
  • 4 replies
  • 2066 views

Is better to talk to a person or do you prefer Alexa?


Some of Marriott’s hotel brands are getting amazon’s Alexa in the guest rooms. Some people have privacy concerns. While other people have adopted Alexa and made her part of their family. So talking to her on vacation might be like feeling at home?

Examples of Alexa’s hospitality uses include ordering room service or asking the device what the swimming pool hours are, today. However, some hotel brands require the human touch. They want you to talk to the Guest Service Representatives (GSRs) and other hotel staff. Some of those hotels don’t even have automated phone answering directories. They want people to answer the phone, after a specific number of rings, and talk to you.

What do you think? Is an Alexa or a Siri a better friend of yours than your hotel’s staff?

https://www.nbcnews.com/nightly-news/video/convenient-or-creepy-thousands-of-hotels-will-soon-have-amazon-s-alexa-by-your-bedside-1258980419939

As a creative professional, you can paint great things in Adobe Photoshop, but can you do it without knowing what happened, centuries ago, in oil paint and watercolor?

When you create vector art, in Adobe Illustrator, do you remember how a T-Square worked on a drawing board?

How about making amazing special effects happen in Adobe Premier Pro? Do you know about splicing film clips together?

When does technology make our world richer and when does it become an excuse for a business to hire less staff?

In some hotels, the GSR is expected to not just check us in, but to come out from behind the front desk, show us around, and make sure our day is going a little bit better than when we walked through the front door. After an insane day of travel, maybe we need a warm handshake, a sincere “thank you,” a complementary bottle of wine, some freshly brewed coffee and conversation, or even a heartfelt hug.

Can Alexa do that, too?

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    4 replies

    haanuman
    Participating Frequently
    August 23, 2018

    Either the cyber security people are weak or the public is getting smarter. As mentioned above that a kid hacked a replica, there are others who can do it for real. The security measures are just not a lot, carelessness and laziness is a disease.

    Brian Stoppee
    Inspiring
    August 27, 2018

    When it comes to any government spending it always comes down to how much of the budget can be allocated.

    Nancy OShea
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    August 27, 2018

    And it vaires by State which is a massive problem.  We so need national election standards.

    Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert
    Nancy OShea
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    August 22, 2018

    Technology cannot be trusted to replace paper ballots. 

    A child hacked a replica of Florida’s voting system in 10 minutes - Vox

    Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert
    Brian Stoppee
    Inspiring
    August 23, 2018

    https://forums.adobe.com/people/Nancy+OShea  wrote

    Technology cannot be trusted to replace paper ballots. 

    A child hacked a replica of Florida’s voting system in 10 minutes - Vox

    This is a good example of the technology of cybersecurity went from something I once understood real well, 10 or so years ago, to being something which moved forward faster than I could keep up.

    I would hope the voting mechanics of democracy is deeply invested in the best cybersecurity, but I would not bet everything on that. It requires the investment of tax revenues. How much do citizens want that to happen?

    John T Smith
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    August 5, 2018

    Not at all related to Alexa

    My wife can take a picture of a plant with her cell phone and send it to other people who know more about plants, to have them send her back the name of the plant

    But she still has to pull weeds with her hands, not her cell phone

    Brian Stoppee
    Inspiring
    August 5, 2018

    https://forums.adobe.com/people/John+T+Smith  wrote

    My wife can take a picture of a plant with her cell phone and send it to other people who know more about plants, to have them send her back the name of the plant

    But she still has to pull weeds with her hands, not her cell phone

    That's a real good example of where technology has assisted us greatly. Janet trained to become a Master Gardener in the late 1990s. That's a program relative to Land Grant colleges and Agricultural Extension Offices. Part of her training was spending something like 50 hours in those offices helping people with their questions and challenges. Today's technologies do make plant identification and problem resolution far better than back when she trained.

    But, when someone's tomato crop is getting a white fuzziness on it, they still need an Extension Agent to take a look at it and advise the person on whether the food source is safe and suggest remedies, if needed.

    Trevor.Dennis
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    August 4, 2018

    Brian is that a non sequitur?  The alternatives do not have to be mutually exclusive — you can use both according to context.

    Do content creation professionals tend to be gadget loving geeks?  Alexa and Google Home are certainly useful, but they are also fun.  You know you are being daft when saying goodnight to Alexa, and it often leads to bizarre conversations between Alexa and my wife and I, trying to think up silly questions for her(it).  This invariably makes us laugh, which is not a bad note to go to  sleep on.

    I'd love the option of asking Alexa for a near instant response to the sort of question that would drive the hotel front desk crazy having answered it 100 times that week.  If it is not that sort of question, then pick up the phone, but you might have to wait.  There is also the Smart Home aspect of these devices.  It is often convenient asking Alexa to turn such and such a light on or off, or to dim it.  It is equally convenient asking Alexa to play a particular song while you are in the kitchen with your hands covered in flower, or ask her to pause when the phone goes.  I like adding items to the shopping list as you think of them, and reading them off my phone when I get to the shops.

    On the minus side, Alexa is a bit of a pedant when it comes to syntax.  Get your words in the wrong order, and comes over all dumb.  Then there is the family whose young daughter managed to buy items from Amazon with no control. (Note: you can turn voice orders off).  Another couple discovered that Alexa had recorded their conversation, and emailed it to someone unknown to either of them.  That person contacted the couple who did not believe it, until he read some of their conversation back to them.

    Alexa is still being developed, and will get smarter, so I don't know how far away we are from the first Terminator.  I didn't have to make this image.  It was already out there on Google,  so people have already had this thought

    The Terminator Alexa Echo Speaker | Comic Con Dates

    Brian Stoppee
    Inspiring
    August 4, 2018

    non sequitur?

    It's a "a conclusion or statement that does not logically follow from the previous argument or statement."