P: Text and symbol generation in images

[Angelic_child5CF3]

I am trying to generate a logo with a desired text. It is not accepting it.

[Angelic_child5CF3]

Text and symbol generation in images is not supported yet in the Text to Image module. The quality of our models will improve with time, and generated content will better respect the prompt. If you are trying to create just text, please try the Text Effects module. (Merging all similar threads here so we can track the number of reports for this)

[CMass]

That is a current limitation of Adobe Firefly. However, you should check out Adobe Express. Specifically the logo templates.  

[Ethereal_Serendipity5CCD]

When I put in a phrase like "Going to the Store" the AI creates an image, often with words, and the words are nonsensical such as "Gooein tausteeren"  No one is ever going to use an AI image with nonsensical gibberish words!  You should have an option to not include words/letters in generation and make it so that if there is going to be words, they're actual words.

[CMass]

@Ethereal_Serendipity5CCD That is a current limitation of most AIs. Here is a post about this limitation if you want to learn more.  I recommend creating an idea in our Idea (feature request) here.

[Lonnie33081757qq7s]

I wanted to highlight that the crucial feature missing in Firefly is accurate text rendering within images. It doesn't necessarily have to have spelling capabilities; it just needs to accurately replicate the text or names when they are part of an image request. In the long run, I'll be sticking with the image generator that excels in this area. I consider this priority #1.

[CMass]

@Lonnie33081757qq7s When you say "accurate text rendering," are you referring to this type of issue: https://community.adobe.com/t5/adobe-firefly-discussions/text-is-wrong-in-text-to-image/m-p/13924887

[johnm6687292]

I instructed to "Create a gold bar on a clear background with the word MUTUAL engraved in the bar." It worked great but it would never spell Mutual correctly. I tried several revisions to no end. Help!

[jane-e]

@johnm6687292 

This is a known issue with AI:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/adobe-firefly-bugs/p-text-is-wrong-in-text-to-image/idc-p/14080489

Jane

[Gilles3D]

I can't seem to create text properly from Firefly (TXT to IMG), for example words on a T-shirt or a building representing a word, text written on a blackboard... Firefly produces the result but alters the text! Does anyone have any ideas?

[Monika Gause]

Try the Text Effects module

Generative AI models have trouble with spelling. And Firefly is no exception. Except for the text effects.

[Erin359880216425]

I tell the AI generator to spell a word and it always spells it wrong.  very frustrating

[Kevin Stohlmeyer]

Text is currently a limitation with all generative AIs.

[Grant37176602n389]

Look at subject

[Mariam Hovhannesyan]

Do you mean you type a text that needs to be in the image? 

[Jill_C]

All AI image generators seem to be quite poor at generating useable text in an image. You should probably open the image in Adobe Express to add the necessary text.

[porterpro]

Generation in firefly text is always incorrect.  

[thatsmauri]

Text-to-image AIs are (still) somewhat bad at writing plain text. This is a current deficiency for most Generative AI models - including Firefly.

The best solution for now is to use e.g. Photoshop to add your desired text in.

[Dave Gustafson]

I'm curious, what was the prompt you were using? I think it says Nashville or something.

[Kartika Rawat]

Hi there!

We appreciate you writing in. You can also review this article for more info on this: https://adobe.ly/4ccCNTC

Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks,

KR

[catparkerphoto]

Every ai item I have created with text has had an issue with the correct spelling of the words entered into the prompt. I rarely ever get a word correctly spelled. What needs to be done to fix this????

[droopydog500]

Hello @catparkerphoto,

Thank you for your message. I am sorry you are having this problem. 

While it has gotten better, Firefly (and most other AI image generators) is generally not good at putting exact text from a prompt into an image. Sometimes it is perfect, but usually, it does not get it right.  The best solution is to use Adobe Express or Photoshop to add text in.  The more complicated the angle or perspective of the text, the more likely you will need Photoshop to get what you want.

Please see this article on why generating text in AI image generators is hard:

If AI image generators are so smart, why do they struggle to write and count?

Thanks,
    droopy

[Dave Gustafson]

What Droopy said is correct. There is a way to "brute force" by creating a structure reference with the word "consulting" spelled out and having Firefly create a logo incorporating that, but it can be hit and miss.

[gabriel3864844024aa]

Digito a palavra e sai em inglês 

[Kevin Stohlmeyer]

@gabriel3864844024aa Firefly and other AI models cannot produce legible text at this time.

[Ignacio3864877064xb]

Cuando le digo que haga una imagen de un logo corporativo abc.com escribe un texto totalmente diferente y sin sentido como xxxabcdexxxxx

[Kevin Stohlmeyer]

@Ignacio3864877064xb No generative AI model can produce legible text at this time.