Skip to main content
Participant
November 19, 2024
Question

The audio quality produced in v2 is worse.

  • November 19, 2024
  • 32 replies
  • 19436 views

I feel that the change from v1 to v2 has resulted in a decrease in the audio quality I produce. Is there a way to downgrade the version from https://podcast.adobe.com/enhance?

32 replies

Participant
December 19, 2024

I'm also looking for v1..  After adobe upgraded the version Currently I'm Not using this.. V1 is More and More Comfortable Sound.. Please Bring V1 or Downgrade us.. 

Participant
December 13, 2024

Couldn't agree more. Sibilant sounds just get lost now to the extent that I've had to stop using it. Fix it or bring back V1!

Participant
December 10, 2024

I have uploaded many different clips and they have all been way worse in v2 than in v1. In v2 I have even taken the same clip that I enhanced in v1 and it has been better in some portions, however, there are certain sections that sound completely different than the rest of the clip; too much bass, too much hissing, and it would not be that noticable if the whole clip was like that, but because it randomly switches in different sections it makes the audio unusable because it's distracting for the viewer/listener. Needless to say, I will not be using this feature anymore unless they fix it or have an opttion to switch back to v1. 

Participant
December 6, 2024

What's honeslty happening to me is that now adobe podcast V2 creates really really weird noises in the silences that are located between words or sentences. Like I'm editing a podcast right now and I find myself spending A LOT OF TIME cleaning these weird noises. And also voices sound compressed and some words are completely distorted in the process. 

Participant
April 4, 2025

This right here. I haven't used v1 so I have no comparison point. Overall, I believe this does a good job of making my audio sound more professional. My hang ups are the weird noises that happen between silences and it's distortion of laughter or chuckles. 😆

Harmony J
Community Manager
Community Manager
December 6, 2024

Thank you all for your thoughtful and candid feedback on Enhance Speech v2! We truly appreciate it and hear you loud and clear. Based on the feedback we’ve received, we’re working to allow free users to be able to select between using v1 and v2, which should be available early in the new year. Stay tuned for more updates!

Harmony Jiroudek, Customer Education & Success | Adobe Podcast
Participating Frequently
December 6, 2024

This is certainly good news for users without an account; however, I wonder if Adobe will revise the V2 version based on the criticism or will it remain as it is? It would be appreciated if you could comment on this.

Harmony J
Community Manager
Community Manager
December 19, 2024

Hi @2331229 , yes thank you for following up on this! We've been hearing that the difference between 0-1% with the slider has caused a lot of confusion, in addition to wanting more control over the mixing with the slider. We're actively working on improving the slider experience with v2 and you should expect to see those improvements in Q1 2025.

Harmony Jiroudek, Customer Education & Success | Adobe Podcast
Participant
November 28, 2024

Yes, I find v2 to be a disappointment as well.  Side by side comparisons of the same audio file shows this.  V2 sounds a bit muffled and my voice distant and even voice volume is lower.  I see now that I can switch between v2 and v1 and thanks for this option.  I look forward to a v3 that improves on v1 but unfortunately v2 remains sub-par.  Just some constructive criticism.

Participant
November 27, 2024

I've noticed V2 has major issues for audio with multiple people. If there's any moments of laughter or slight talking over each other, audio is destroyed. V1 for the win

Participant
November 26, 2024

V2 of Adobe Podcast Enhance is just horrendous, V1 was surely not perfect but it was incredible to use and I really put the Adobe company in high regards because of this AI tool, V1 allowed me to make my voice-over audio clear and crisp with the inclusion of Adobe Audition, I depended on it to be able to do my work as a voice actor but now it is basically useless, this version has ultimately affected my work and clients have noticed how robotic V2 sounds, the noise leveling is pathetic now, V2 causes my voice to be muffled at the beginning and at the end of my voice recording which is inconsistent, I do not understand why Adobe keeps breaking things which were not even broken in the first place, you do not need to keep updating the AI tools because this what it leads to, bring back V1 or sadly people will start using Adobe Podcast less. Honestly, if  you want a good alternative just use Auphonic, it is a bit pricy but it will definitely get the job done, it is 40x better than V1 and V2 of Adobe Podcast combined.

Participant
January 16, 2025

how come you say the V2 sounds more robotic than the V1? In my opinion, V1 is how you are describing V2, + 100x worse. V2 is expentionally better, while also being not the best, but I truly dont understand how you think V1 is better

Participant
November 25, 2024

V2 is a downgrade. In addition to what others have said, V2 tends to clip low-level voice, and it consistently mutes laughter and chuckling, which is part of the natural audio. I will say that it's great at taking out noise.

 

Participant
November 25, 2024

Can we have an option to choose back to V1. V2 is worst.