Recording in ASIO has robot sound

I recently recorded a phone interview with ASIO with a buffer of 128. While recording, it sounded fine in the headphones but on playback it sounds like a robot. I did notice a lag between the timeline curser and the waveform but didn't think anything of it at the time. Is there a way to fix this? I was using the Rodecaster Pro II as my console but recorded into the computer and not on the console.