Skip to main content
malinl60759647
Participant
June 8, 2018
Answered

Clipping masks in Illustrator vs Indesign

  • June 8, 2018
  • 1 reply
  • 599 views

Hi,

When you place images in InDesign, it automatically turns the frame into a clipping mask. If I resize the object, the image will be cropped but remain its proportions. Unless I hold down the command key; then the image will resize as well.

In Illustrator however, you have to create a clipping mask manually. And in order to resize the clipping mask, you have to double click the item before you're able to. So instead of just holding down a key (like in Indesign), you have to double click and go to isolation mode first. When you're working with multiple images on a document, this gets pretty frustrating.

I love how it works in InDesign. It's quick and easy. I always use clipping masks when I work with images; saves me cropping it in photoshop plus I'm able to move it around and use the image from it's best angle.

Now, my question is, is there a setting somewhere that enables this feature in Illustrator, and make it work the same as in InDesign?

Thanks,

Lin

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer John Mensinger

No, there is no setting to change. Illustrator's implementation of the clipping mask is older than the InDesign application itself, and they really are two different features. While I understand your analogy, technically, InDesign's image frames are not clipping masks in the same sense; they are just endowed with behaviors that allow manipulation of the frame independently of the image.

1 reply

John Mensinger
Community Expert
John MensingerCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
June 8, 2018

No, there is no setting to change. Illustrator's implementation of the clipping mask is older than the InDesign application itself, and they really are two different features. While I understand your analogy, technically, InDesign's image frames are not clipping masks in the same sense; they are just endowed with behaviors that allow manipulation of the frame independently of the image.