Copy link to clipboard
Copied
When I work with transparencies in InDesign, the text on the page always appears bolder (even when exported). What could be causing this? This happens in both RGB and CMYK color modes. The text is on the top layer.
100 % Opacity:
Less than 100 % Opacity (50%)
<Title renamed by MOD>
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Apparently it has nothing to do with the reduction.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
How are you exporting the file? What format and what settings?
I will go ahead and assume PDF, and an older version that includes flattening. Flattened PDFs do not contain transparency, so anyplace transparency is used has to be saved in a way that blends the colours, images, objects, and text to retain the same appearance. This usually requires text to be converted to outlines.
Text in Opentype or Truetype formats includes hinting, which optimises the appearance of text at low resolutions to make it more legible and more closely resemble how it will appear at high resolution. Paths, which is what outlined text is, do not benefit from hinting, so usually look a bit bolder.
Imagine drawing a circle on graph paper, then filling in each grid square within the circle. Some grid lines are entirely outside the circle, so those are white. Some are entirely within the circle, so those are black. But any square with the path of the circle on it must either be white or black. That's the decision your PDF viewer is making when it converts the paths of the text to pixels on your monitor. If the grid squares are very small, the bolding appearance is minimised. The RIP in your printer (assuming the file will be printed on a high resolution press) is very high resolution. The lack of hinting on some text is almost imperceptible.
There are ways to minimise the bolding effect by minimizing where text is outlines when flattened. You can save in a PDF format that does not flatten. You can put the text on a layer above any transparency, so the text is unaffected by flattening. You can use Acrobat to convert all text to outlines, which will remove hinting from all text so there is no contrast between flattened and unflattened text.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
thank you for the answers. I will read through everything carefully and try it out
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
As @Scott Falkner explained - it's not a bug but a display "problem".
If you try to edit text affected by transparency - it will be OK for a few seconds - then switches to "thicker" version - or vice versa, sorry, I'm on my phone right now.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
thank you for the answers! 🙂
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Well, I use the latest version of InDesign and Acrobat. The problem occurs when exporting for print as well as digital. And also with different fonts (in the example Noto Sans). I don't quite understand why this isn't seen as a bug, because other programs (e.g. Affinity) don't have any problems with transparencies. To be honest, I'm a bit surprised.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Is the text on a layer above all other objects as it should be?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi, yes it is.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Thank you; this bring something for export, which is now the same. But I won't be able to improve the preview in the program, will I?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Is the file set to Edit > Transparency Blend Space... > RGB?
Are all the placed artwork files on the page also RGB for the sake of colorspace agreement?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Thank you; this bring something for export, which is now the same. But I won't be able to improve the preview in the program, will I?