Skip to main content
johnrellis
Legend
May 25, 2025

P: Lens corrections don't work with HDRs merged from DNGs

  • May 25, 2025
  • 7 replies
  • 560 views

Lens corrections don't work with Photo Merge HDRs merged from DNGs. They do work correctly with DNGs not produced by Photo Merge.

 

Tested with LR 14.3.1 / Mac OS 15.5:

 

1. Download and open this catalog: 

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/vhm0r8s17csaatgs153pw/hdr-dng-lens-profile-bug.zip?rlkey=6i2o4jgomfzpfbj8gm4eizak8&dl=0 

 

It contains raws from five cameras: Canon EOS R6m2, Fujifilm X-T5,  Nikon Z 7_2, ODS OM-1, Sony ILCE-7C. All the raws have Lens Corrections > Enable Profile Corrections checked.

 

2. Observe that for each camera, there are three stacks containing these stack tops:

 

- an HDR made from two copies of the original raw, e.g. DSC_0102-HDR.dng.

 

- an HDR made from full-resolution DNGs exported from two copies  of the raw with the options Image Format: DNG, Lossy Compression, e.g. DSC_0102-full.dng.

 

- an HDR made from reduced-resolution DNGs exported from two copies of the raw with the options Image Format: DNG, Lossy Compression, and Resize To Fit: Long Edge = 3000, e.g. DSC_0102-small.dng.

 

3. For each camera, compare the three HDRs in Loupe.  Observe that the HDR merged from reduced-resolution DNGs is missing some corrections for distortion and vignetting compared to the DNG merged from raws. E.g. DSC09289-small.dng versus DSC09289-HDR.dng.

 

4. Observe that for the Nikon Z 7_2 only, the HDR merged from the full-resolution DNGs is missing corrections for vignetting (DSC_0102-full-HDR versus DSC_0102-HDR.dng). But for the other four cameras, the DNGs merged from full-resolution DNGs have the correct lens corrections.

 

5. Compare a raw with its corresponding full-resolution and reduced-resolution DNGs. E.g. DSC09289.ARW, DSC09289-full.dng, and DSC09289-small.dng. Observe that they look identical and that the DNGs aren't missing lens corrections.

 

7 replies

Known Participant
June 21, 2025

I borrowed a Canon EOS R7 and a Sigma 10-18mm F2.8 and made some test shoots and did the whole proces. With this combination the HDR merged from reduced-resolution DNGs is missing the lens corrections for distortion and vignetting compared to original files. The problem does not show with full resolution merges.

johnrellis
Legend
June 11, 2025

@Erik36545164gcm6: "when an update arrives, will there the published a document/list of things that have been addressed so I can find out if the issue is solved?"

 

Do the LR menu command Help > What's New to get a low-density marketing overview with a link to the fixed issues. Or visit here for a higher-density, generally more complete list:

https://www.lightroomqueen.com/whatsnew/

Known Participant
June 11, 2025

@johnrellis Thanks for clarifying that. Just a small question: So when an update arrives, will there the published a document/list of things that have been addressed so I can find out if the issue is solved?

johnrellis
Legend
June 8, 2025

@Erik36545164gcm6, Adobe rarely comments on when a bug will be fixed. Lightroom Classic and the rest of the Lightroom / Camera Raw ecosystem generally get released every eight weeks. So we might expect to see LR 14.4 the weeks of June 16 or 23.

Known Participant
June 8, 2025

@Rikk Flohr: Photography  Any update on this issue?

Rikk Flohr_Photography
Community Manager
May 26, 2025

Updating status

 

Rikk Flohr: Adobe Photography Org
johnrellis
Legend
May 26, 2025

Also, note that if you do Photo Merge > HDR on smart previews rather than exported reduced-resolution DNGs, the resulting DNG also has the same problem with incorrect lens corrections.  Not surprising, since a smart preview is simply a reduced-resolution DNG.