P: Generative Remove Feedback (Lr Classic & Lr Eco)

[Rikk Flohr: Photography]

This post applies to Lightroom Classic and the Lightroom Ecosystem products.

Camera Raw feedback can be found here.

Generative Remove makes it easier to remove unwanted objects and distractions with a simple gesture, even on complex backgrounds. For more accurate results, be sure to include the object's shadow in your selection and/or expand its size. 

Detect Objects uses AI to find the objects underneath a brushed area. The masked areas will now appear larger than the Early Access version of this feature. You can also circle objects for quicker selection now. 

We have also updated the spot selection experience to make it easier to manage variations, switch the fill type, refine the selection area, or re-generate as needed. 

Batch updating is also now supported for Generative Remove spots. 

Try out the latest updates and share your feedback with us here. Please also include the following details in your post: 

• App version
• System details
• Example image(s) if you wish to share

Our team continually monitors this thread to track issues for future improvement. Thanks!

Lisa Ngo: Lightroom Product Manager

Posted by:

[photobrad]

Please...for the love of god!!!!! stop putting random objects back in when we use the remove tool.  It is not.....the replace object tool.  it is the remove tool.    

Stop putting objects back in.....remove the what we are trying to remove, rebuild the background to match and stop!!!!!

[Rikk Flohr: Photography]

@photobrad 

See: https://www.lightroomqueen.com/generative-remove-replace/ 
Also see: https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-discussions/p-new-ai-powered-generative-remove-earl...

These two posts will aid you in using the tool to get better results.

[photobrad]

No!!!!!!!

fix your tool!!!!

there are 652 posts here most of which telling you the same thing.  Idk what Victoria Bampton wants everone to do.  

fix ths blessed thing!!!!  Remove what we need.  

tell your g d ai system to NEVER EVER replace what we highligted.  Always remove it.  

make a secondary tool called the REPLACE object tool if u must but as it exists rn in LR....its beyond frustrating to use and always for the same reason.  Stop dancing around the problem several hundred people told you is the problem and just fix it!!!!!

[John R Ellis]

@photobrad: "Idk what Victoria Bampton wants everyone to do."

That's likely the reason you're not getting good results. Take a few minutes to read that article to learn how to use LR Generative Remove. As it says, "Like any tool, you need to know how to use it properly to get the best results."

"It adds another object like 70% of the time in LR!! maybe 15% in PS"

Generative Remove in LR and PS use the same algorithm, but because LR has non-destructive editing, you have to spend 30 seconds to learn how to handle cropping with LR's Remove. (That isn't an issue with PS, which destructively removes cropped-out pixels.)

But if the article doesn't help, then you must have plenty of examples where LR does poorly compared to PS.  Show everyone that we're blind idiots by attaching here full-resolution JPEGs exported from the unmodified original photos (not screenshots).

"there are 652 posts here most of which telling you the same thing"

There are far fewer than 652 posts of people complaining that Remove "replaces" rather than "removes". A large number of the posts concern a catalog upgrade bug with Update AI Settings in LR 14.0, which was quickly fixed by LR 14.0.1 two days later, and there are a fair number of posts about connectivity/firewall problems and outdated graphics drivers.

As of 11/5, 34 people had provided problem photos where they had trouble removing objects. With all of these, we were able to show how to remove the objects easily using the simple techniques described in the article. Since then, there have been some more problem photos posted, with the same results. See here for a listing of all those posts:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-discussions/p-generative-remove-feedback-lr-classic...

[AHunt]

I was revisiting an image that I had previously worked on. I used the LrC Remove tool in several places. When I revisited the image, I updated a mask and added a new Ai mask (Sky, I believe). After that the Remove icon had a red dot under it so I opened Remove and clicked Update All. It totally redid one of the Remove spots I had previously done, with a very different result. I had followed the recommendations in LR Queen's post and had successfully removed an item. When I clcked Update All, it apparently totally redid the Remove and added in something totally new. I had to undo and just ignore the red dot under the Remove icon.

Alan Hunt

[C.Cella]

@AHunt 

What you report should not be happening.
Currently in LrC Generative Remove should not be changed upon updating Ai Maks.

.What you describe sounds like the bug that LrC 14 introduced.

.Did you update to he latest version of LrC 14.1 ?

[photobrad]

Thats just a crap response. There are almost 700 people telling you that its a problem and here you say that?!?!?

Obviously you don’t actually use this tool. And yes i keep mine updated!!!!!!

It adds another object like 70% of the time in LR!! maybe 15% in PS. But that means i have to try and fail in lr a couple tomes. Them edit in ps…..nad them go nack to LR all of which takes time!!!!! And is pisses me noff every g d time!

Its a great tool when it works. You guys need to re generate the parameters of the ai to NOT EVER REPLACE. ALWAYS REMOVE.

MAKE ANOTHER TOOL THAT REPLACES IF U MUST. BUT STOP!!!!!!:stop_sign: replacing stuffnow!!


Thank you so much and have a great day!

Sent from my iPhone

[AHunt]

Yes, I updated to 14.0.1. I wasn't aware that this had been reported as a bug. Thanks for your response. I'll watch for a fix. My system info is below.

Alan Hunt

Lightroom Classic version: 14.0.1 [ 202410161356-30922cfc ]
License: Creative Cloud
Language setting: en
Operating system: Windows 11 - Home Premium Edition
Version: 11.0.22631
Application architecture: x64
System architecture: x64
Logical processor count: 20
Processor speed: 2.9GHz
SqLite Version: 3.36.0
CPU Utilisation: 0.0%
Power Source: Plugged In
Built-in memory: 65220.6 MB
Dedicated GPU memory used by Lightroom: 3302.3MB / 5996.0MB (55%)
Real memory available to Lightroom: 65220.6 MB
Real memory used by Lightroom: 3373.1 MB (5.1%)
Virtual memory used by Lightroom: 8034.5 MB
GDI objects count: 975
USER objects count: 2431
Process handles count: 2872
Memory cache size: 252.5MB
Internal Camera Raw version: 17.0 [ 2043 ]
Maximum thread count used by Camera Raw: 5
Camera Raw SIMD optimization: SSE2,AVX,AVX2
Camera Raw virtual memory: 612MB / 32610MB (1%)
Camera Raw real memory: -187MB / 65220MB (0%)

[Patrice8005]

When I use Generative Remove and hit the Generate Button the eraser and marks remain so I cannot see the changes underneith until I close it, also if I want to see Variations 1-3 I can't because the eraser and marks are still there until I close it.

[John R Ellis]

@Patrice8005: "the eraser and marks remain so I cannot see the changes underneath until I close it"

Set Tool Overlay to Auto, and when you move the mouse off of the photo, the brush outlines and eraser icons will disappear:

You can also use the keyboard shortcut H to cycle Tool Overlay between Always and Never.

[Playful_Wonder5EF7]

Hi! The remove works great! But lately I've been getting this weird outline or difference in tone. Im not sure what's going on or how to fix it. 

[John R Ellis]

@Playful_Wonder5EF7: "I've been getting this weird outline or difference in tone. "

Generative Remove sometimes doesn't do a good job of matching the tone of uniform backgrounds. See this post for how to blend the boundary using the healing brush:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-discussions/p-generative-remove-feedback-lr-classic...

[startbov999]

I tried all of the suggestions in the article and remove still doesn't work. I have to move to photoshop which works perfectly then return to lightroom. Definitely a pain. Lightroom remove just replaces with another oject. Help. This is not like you guys.

[John R Ellis]

@startbov999: "I have to move to photoshop which works perfectly then return to lightroom. Definitely a pain. Lightroom remove just replaces with another object."

If the object is on the edge of the photo and PS removes it easily, that usually indicates you're applying Remove on top of cropping -- Remove tries to match the unselected, cropped-out pixels.  Undo any Crop, Transform, and Lens Correction settings, apply Remove, then redo those settings.

If that doesn't help, please attach a full-resolution JPEG exported from the unmodified original photo (not a screenshot), so we and Adobe can see the issue in detail. With nearly every of the several dozen problem photos posted here, we've been able to show how to quickly remove the desired objects.

[Fran38403119vd93]

Tengo el problema de que al editar una fotografia y usar mascaras y IA generativa No se me guardan los ajustes. siempre manda actualizar para que vuelvan aparacer la edicion

[John R Ellis]

@Fran38403119vd93: "I have the problem that when I edit a photo and use masks and generative AI, the settings are not saved. It always sends an update so that the edit appears again."

See if this helps:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-discussions/problems-with-ai-in-masks-and-remove-to...