Skip to main content
H
Hematita
Participant
May 23, 2023

P: Generated images violate user guidelines

 

So as you can see, it's a PG-13 relatively inoffensive image of a woman in a bunny outfit. The top worked fine, and I was able to complete the top ear, which is cool. When I tried to extend the bottom with generative fill, though, I got this warning. They're just a pair of legs wearing stockings, and I wanted to extend it.

It feels like a false flag - though I could be wrong? I find myself thinking it would do the same for women in swimsuits.

Figured I'd share here.

    1084 replies

    Show previous replies
    F
    fanceygirl
    Participant
    August 14, 2023

    I have been using Photoshop Beta for the last few days with no problems but today I was editing a photo of a wedding. The Bride and her mother was in her bedroom as there was good light from the window however a part of the bed was in the photo and I tried to remove it with the generative fill and it gives me a message saying I am in violation of guidelines. I don't understand. there is no nudity or terrorism or violance..Just a bride and her mother and the part of a bed, which I want to remove.

     

      J.C. Scott
      J.C. Scott
      Inspiring
      August 13, 2023

      You know, it would be great if I could use Generative AI, but in the last few days, it's become almost unusable for my needs. Attempting to fix anything attached to an individual results in a violation notice most of the time. For God's sake, Adobe, do something about this. I realize it's a beta, but this issue is getting worse.

      OS: Windows 10

      PS Beta: Current version

        daniellei4510
        Community Expert
        daniellei4510Community Expert
        Community Expert
        August 13, 2023

        It would be helpful if you could show us what you are trying to accomplish. Generative Fill is not and will never be the be all and end all of editing in Photosho, even when it is out of beta. I've seen so many instances where edits could have been accomplished with tools that have been available in Photoshop for years as well as more recently. 

        Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
        J.C. Scott
        J.C. Scott
        Inspiring
        August 13, 2023
        quote

        It would be helpful if you could show us what you are trying to accomplish. Generative Fill is not and will never be the be all and end all of editing in Photosho, even when it is out of beta. I've seen so many instances where edits could have been accomplished with tools that have been available in Photoshop for years as well as more recently. 


        By @daniellei4510

         

        This is one of many examples. I generate AI art, and my use case is often defect removal. For this particular example, I could use something like Content Aware Fill or simply fill it in manually, but the former doesn't do the job as well as it could, which leaves some cleanup, and the latter would take a lot longer than using Generative AI.

         

        Another example:

         

        Graham24508943nobd
        Graham24508943nobd
        Known Participant
        August 12, 2023

        I've had heaps of NSFW images generated. Adobe needs to look at their own stock first

          daniellei4510
          Community Expert
          daniellei4510Community Expert
          Community Expert
          August 12, 2023

          I know this does nothing to fix what appears to be a bug, but may I suggest going the old-fashioned way? I selected the horse's nose, copied it, pasted it, turned it black, and gave it a little blur.

          Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
            hectorgomezcreative
            hectorgomezcreative
            Known Participant
            August 12, 2023

            I get this error in most of the generative fills with people/models.... I think Adobe is trying to protect themselves from creating NSFW images but it's taking it to absurd extremes...

              T
              tl78737245
              Participant
              August 12, 2023

              Prompt "remove person" might help you here. 

                P
                positive_yogi98A4
                Participant
                August 12, 2023

                See attached image. Just want to clear the arm so the shadow of the horse is complete. So no violate guidline was violated. Got this alot. Also when I am just working on a horse to get rid of some line.

                 

                Not (yet) good Adobe.

                  daniellei4510
                  Community Expert
                  daniellei4510Community Expert
                  Community Expert
                  August 12, 2023

                  I hear ya. Gen Fill is a long ways from being perfect at this point and I suspect that there will always be (for now, at least) a need to use traditional editing tools to fix what Gen Fill doesn't. I have found this to be the case for all AI programs, even the best of the line. 

                  Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
                    T
                    tl78737245
                    Participant
                    August 12, 2023

                    Thank you. Yes it is possible to expand on the selection and get some results but the muscling of the horse in this area (where the base of it's neck meets it's chest) are pretty specific. It would be nice if the simple task of removing a rope could be achieved.

                      daniellei4510
                      Community Expert
                      daniellei4510Community Expert
                      Community Expert
                      August 12, 2023

                      Not quite sure what I'm looking at here, but I made a larger selection outside of your own selection, used a "." for the prompt, and I ended up with this.

                      Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
                        Show more replies
                        Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
                        Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices