Skip to main content
Rob Ainscough
Inspiring
May 22, 2013
Question

Batch execution of Export prompts for JPEG info?

  • May 22, 2013
  • 1 reply
  • 1221 views

My goal is simple:

Take many .JPG images, resize them, set their quality to 60, and save to file.  Simple right?

I can't seem to make this work.  I've tried recording "Save for Web" (Adobe lists it as an Export) and input the size adjust changes in the Export dialog and set the quality to 60 and hit the Save button.  Stop recording.

Now I Automate - Batch and selection my Action and setup the source and destination folders.  The batch runs but it doesn't do what I recorded in the Action?  Here are the problems:

1.  Image is not resized (apparently seems to ignore all my input in Save for Web dialog)?

2.  I'm being prompt by a JPEG save options dialog for each file?  Why?

To work around #1 issue, I did the Resize via the Image | Image Size and then "Save for Web" ... but I'm still prompted with JPEG save options (quality settings) when I run my batch using my action.

It seems "Save for Web" just doesn't work for recorded actions, even though I see the "Export" and it does indeed list all the correct settings I used.  I see no way to really "edit" recorded actions?

Are Actions an "afterthought" because they really don't seem to be very useful and more often than not require a lot of experimentation and in some cases frustration.  The time it takes to "develop" an action that works is often longer than if I just did the tasks manually ... I can't see this as being helpful to an end user like myself.

I've gone thru Adobe Press books and they spend maybe 2-3 pages on Actions/Batch and that's it -- such an import tool and it only gets brief mention?  So I'm coming to the conclusion that "Actions" and "Batch" are primitive at best case ... am I missing something?  Are there better tools to do this?

Thanks, Rob.

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

Inspiring
May 22, 2013

I will admit I've not used actions in some time but… have you turned off the dialog toggles in the action pallete…? Do seek help in the general forum too… Many more users there use actions too…

Rob Ainscough
Inspiring
May 22, 2013

I was able to get it to do what I wanted eventually.  Solutions is to NOT use the "Save to Web" dialog.

To get the batch working I did the following during an Action recording:

1.  Standard Image Resize (not from Save to Web dialog)

2.  Use "Save As" and select JPEG quality options

I was able to successfully use this Action in a Batch on an entire folder of images and get them all resized the quality adjusted and put in a new folder -- without any need for my interaction.

Is there an alternative to "Actions"?

Thanks, Rob.

Inspiring
May 22, 2013

Yes script is an alternative to actions… Users of this forum are mostly scripters… Where your action just plays out over multi-files with a set of pre-recorded of parameters and may fail if the curcumstances are not correct. Script allows for conditional logic you can make all sorts of decisions of what to do and when… Change course during the execution and such… Much more flexible but a fair bit more complex to too. You need to have a basic knowledge of Visual Basic, AppleScript or JavaScript to get you started…