Skip to main content
C
Contemporary_Dave
Known Participant
October 17, 2018
Answered

Crop Tool Issue With CC2019 - Possible Bug?

  • October 17, 2018
  • 14 replies
  • 15031 views

Just noticed something odd with the crop tool in CC2019. This only happens in Classic Crop mode.

When you want to do a custom crop with W x H x resolution selected with the size and resolution boxes left blank, the crop remains in the same aspect ratio if you try to lengthen/shorten one side of the crop.

Has anyone had the same issue - and how do you resolve this?

      This topic has been closed for replies.
      Correct answer Akash Sharma

      Thanks for sharing the video. As davescm has mentioned, I believe that this is related to the new transform behavior change in the 20.0 Photoshop update.

      See the below screengrab:

      Source New and enhanced features | Latest release of Photoshop CC

      ~Akash

      14 replies

      Show previous replies
      S
      Stu Allen
      Participating Frequently
      October 17, 2018

      I have the same problem.

      stefan113
      stefan113
      Participant
      October 17, 2018

      I have exactly the same issue and it's very frustrating. It must be a bug!
      Holding the SHIFT key solves the problem in some way, but its still a lot more complicated than in the earlier version.

      C-Marc
      C-Marc
      Participant
      October 17, 2018

      I have found the same problem.

      Holding the SHIFT key makes it work like it is supposed to.

      Akash Sharma
      Akash Sharma
      Legend
      October 17, 2018

      Hi Contemporary_Dave,

      Sorry that the Crop tool in Photoshop CC 20.0 version is now working as expected.

      If I am following you correctly, with the crop tool in use if I leave the resolution field left empty I am able to crop the image as expected.

      Would you like to share a few screenshots of what's happening at your end?

      Thanks,

      Akash

      C
      Contemporary_DaveAuthor
      Known Participant
      October 17, 2018

      Thanks for getting back to me. See video here: PS Crop error - YouTube

      D
      denisr704218734737017
      Inspiring
      December 19, 2018

      Thanks for sharing the video. As davescm has mentioned, I believe that this is related to the new transform behavior change in the 20.0 Photoshop update.

      See the below screengrab:

      Source New and enhanced features | Latest release of Photoshop CC

      ~Akash


      Really thought it was a bug (or that my shift key was locked somehow).

      As far as I can remember, shift has always been required to scale proportionally.

      Why reverse this kind of well established behavior overnight? It's not even consistent with other CC software (I've just checked in Illustrator).

      Maybe a user setting would be more convenient, if some users really prefer the new behavior.

        Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
        Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices