Skip to main content
Participant
September 19, 2022
Question

How to not Smart objects can not edit borders tools grayed out

  • September 19, 2022
  • 2 replies
  • 723 views

Does anyone know why you can't add a simple border to a "smart" object? Why is everything so limited with them? It's so frustrating! Why even have an option you can't edit on software meant for editing?! And why do the most basic functions take 22 steps? I can add a border to the same image in MAC pages with a simple click! They figured out a way... then again, they're probably not relying on a million how-to tutorials either... so disappointed after all the money it costs just to have PS....you'd think it would be the opposite...

This topic has been closed for replies.

2 replies

Trevor.Dennis
Community Expert
Community Expert
September 19, 2022

You can easily add a border to a Smart Object.  If you want to add the border outside the existing pixels, you need to add some Canvas to accommodate the border. It can be advisable to add canvas uniformly to avoid the SO being moved from its original location.  

D Fosse
Community Expert
Community Expert
September 19, 2022

The short answer is don't use smart objects, stick with regular layers. You apparently don't need that level of complexity.

 

It's always been a basic rule of smart objects that you cannot alter pixels directly in it. No painting, no cloning, etc.

 

A smart object is a pretty complex thing. It is not the image itself, but a representation of it. An image of an image, so to speak. But that makes a lot of things possible, that wouldn't be possible on a normal layer.

 

You can either rasterize the smart object, to turn it into a standard regular layer, or open the smart object and do your edits, then close and save.

 

 

Participant
September 19, 2022
  • I appreciate your time and feedback. I'm not trying to change the photo itself...all I want is a simple border around the image with square edges. And if the option is grayed out by being a smart object...there's no alternative. I've watched every tutorial on how to add this one very simple stupid effect and my conclusion is it just shouldn't be this difficult. It's so basic. Sometimes I just need to do some quick edits, and apparently Photoshop is just not set up for that. Thank you for reading my response, and again, for your time and feedback. It is appreciated. 
Participant
September 19, 2022

I'm starting to believe all my other photog friends that it's set up to be so complicated just to have all the tutorials...