Is there a way to create replacement puzzle pieces?

[johns15802288]

I am very new to photoshop and have this challenge... Is there a way to create replacement puzzle pieces? I am thinking that either a repair or replace type option. The overview probably doesn't have enough detail but may be a good basis and then heal to try get the look and color more similar - I do want to keep the puzzle piece lines so we can print and cut out.

[Ally2299770459xt]

You're in luck, cause yes, I can tell you how to make a replacement puzzle piece if one went missing

[Rafael Aviles]

Here is my version, I hope it helps.