Skip to main content
Known Participant
April 2, 2023
Question

Liquify multiple layers

  • April 2, 2023
  • 1 reply
  • 3170 views

So, I use Photoshop to paint sometimes, and I'm relatively new to the program. Let's say I have my lineart (inks) and the paint/colors itself in separate layers. When I'm painting characters, I sometimes need to use liquify to fix some of their features, like a slightly tilted or elongated muzzle, etc. The problem is that if I select multiple layers, and try to use liquify, it simply gets grayed out.

 

Using liquify in one layer at a time is not an option because it would never yield the same results in both layers and it would get pretty inconvenient really quickly. Like i can't believe liquifying multiple layers at once is not possible, how hard can it be to implement? Other apps already do this. (On the topic of liquifying... how do I toggle the preview on and off? So that I can see the before and after. I'm using CC 2014 and it doesn't seem to be an option? Unless there's a workaround or keyboard shortcut).

 

Also, using smart objects feels really overkill for just doing some painting. If I really do want to liquify multiple layers at the same time, "without" merging them, using smart objects seem like the only option. So I have to select both layers and turn it into a smart object, in order to liquify them. And it doesn't let me preserve the layers if I want to rasterize it again to keep painting on separate layers anyways, so using smart objects is effectively useless for my needs. I do not want my lineart to be ultimately merged with the paint. And I'm surely not going to a separate file to edit the contents, save it, and then come back to my main file. Not only is it inconvenient but it also disrupts my workflow. I need to see those layers in the context of the rest of my layers, not in an isolated instance.

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

Stephen Marsh
Community Expert
Community Expert
April 2, 2023

@grunge616 – You need to make use of the save mesh and load (last) mesh features to apply the previous transform to another layer.

grunge616Author
Known Participant
April 2, 2023

Dear Stephen,

Is there a way I can avoid having to do that? Or do you think for my use case I'm better off without messing with smart filters even if it's destructive? It's not super accurate work anyways, just me using PS to paint.

Stephen Marsh
Community Expert
Community Expert
April 2, 2023

I don't think that smart objects are the way to go for your workflow, however, only you can decide what works best for you.

 

I would go with separate layers and using the previous/saved mesh to  reproduce the liquify edits of one layer to related layers.