Participant

Question

Photoshop and midi controller

Forum|Forum|13 years ago
June 20, 2012
5 replies
29494 views

I work for a company and do image processing all most on a production level. We are looking in new ways to streamline our process. One feature we are looking at is using midi controllers, setting a row of buttons that take you thru the process. Just wondering if any one else uses such a device like this or any device that is not a keyboard. Looking to see what other professionals use

Thank you, Andrew

S

Sami_PA

Known Participant

I'm bringing this topic up from the dead because, well it's valid.

I woujld like to propose that photoshop include:

- integration of midi as an extension of keyboard shortcuts

- Being able to assign these to actions

- Map sliders for HSL/RGB/Brightness/Opacity

- Being able to plug in apps like Metagrid directly so they can directly call actions without a hotkey assignment.

With the popularity of applications like Metagrid/Streamdeck/Keyboard Maestro, etc I can't understand how this hasn't been implemented. I have approximately 50-100 different actions in photoshop and along with all the keyboard shortcuts, it's hard to keep track which is why i love digital keyboards. Not being able to map these directly slows everything down, even though I have actioned what I can, run a tablet, and use keyboard maestro and Metagrid.

Come on Photoshop. You got this - please add it.

A

angel77777

Participant

I think MIDI would be usefull if you consider to;

-control wheels and sliders (if you send hotkeys with you wacom wheel you can experience that there is a lag sending hotkeys)

-have a visual feedback on your midi controller (ex: the use pressure state is ON? OFF? con you send back this state to my midi controller?)

If there is some Adobe coder reading that post please write to me at:

email removed by moderator

S

smurphy2342

Inspiring

For anyone interested, this is THE answer!!!: http://controllermate.com/ It allows you to fully change the buttons of any connector controller, including the internal keyboard. It has been AMAZING for combining several steps into a single key press! Check it out if you're interested. Then you can explore external controllers to command. These X-keys look pretty good and come in various sizes: http://www.piengineering.com/xkeys.php

C

Cody Ranaldo

Participant

I also thought about controllermate-- but (at least as far as what i'm looking for) afaik theres no way to point say, one knob to affect the red/cyan highlight correction in the color balance tool--

Chris Cox

Legend

Graphics tablets (like wacom) use a number of buttons and keys, and people use them all the time with Photoshop.

But mostly they are emulating the keyboard.

Don Quinn

Participating Frequently

In the realm of graphics, I have seen MIDI used for live performance capture of animated characters/puppets. But I cannot imagine how this would be useful to an image editing program. If there is a pre-defined "process", then there may not be a need for the live improvisation of an artist using MIDI controls. There is already an ability to run actions based on hotkeys assigned to your keyboard.

Can you give a very basic example of how you would see this working?

S

smurphy2342

Inspiring

The idea to use the MIDI controller is meant to take away some of the thinking required for the keyboard shortcuts. Set a row of buttons for each step of the process and then just run down the row of buttons to complete the function. In the current process there are many different multi-key shortcuts pressed. The hopes with the MIDI being that you no longer need to think of which keyboard shortcut to use for the next step or have to press several keyboard buttons to perform a function. A process like: 1. Save As..., 2. paste in a name, 3. add "_pv" to the end of the name, 3. hit return, and then 4. Close" can all be programmed into one MIDI controller button. Some of the more advanced programming is where we're having issues (ike programming a turn dial to control brush opacity or size).

S

smurphy2342

Inspiring

I suspect not everyone has a step by step start-to-finish process they need to follow, so your scenario is kind of specific to your uses.

I don't use a tablet, but I do a lot of Photoshop work, and I find the keyboard has become very natural for me to use. I don't think about the shortcuts I use; after a while they just become direct "muscle memory". Pretty much the same as a musical instrument, I'd say - after gaining good familiarity with the instrument, the musician starts to just think about the music.

And of course there are the F keys at the top of the keyboard, which can be assigned to things.

On another front, it seems to me there's some kind of UI integration with Apple portable electronic devices that hasn't been mentioned here yet... Introduced in Photoshop CS5.5, you rest a hand on the iPad or iPhone and do gestures. I've not tried it, personally. Did you investigate that?

-Noel

Yes, the scenario is specific to our users...or to a mass production house. We are a production house for a retail website and each retoucher has to do similar steps to to about 150 images each day. We use Wacom tablets (which we couldn't live without), have many specific hot keys and have scripted as much as we can but in our world of very quick turnaround all the time we can save the more we can retouch the sooner items are on the website. That is where this MIDI exploration comes in. It's not that the keyboard is a hinderance but there are more variables to deal with and more limitations that cost us precious seconds. Pretty crazy how seconds count. If our ten retouchers can save five seconds per image that extrapolates to some 500 hours of saved time per year. In retail, that is HUGE!

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded