Skip to main content
Participant
March 12, 2019
Question

Photoshop Soft Brush banding problem

  • March 12, 2019
  • 2 replies
  • 8045 views

I am having a problem with my soft brushes in Photoshop CC'19. I am trying to clean up the background of a portrait photo, but the soft brush is creating some obvious banding. If I colour over a simple white background, the brush paints on with a smooth(ish) gradient. As soon as I put it in my dark grey background, the banding is obvious. Here is one example below. The same black layer over the top of a white background, and then removed. You can see that the one on the pixels has unattractive banding compared to the white.

Here is the photograph which I am trying to edit (lightened to see the banding easier).

Above you can see that I have added some colour to the edges to create a landscape photograph. I am trying to blend it in to the photo so there is not a harsh edge.

Below, you can see that the soft brush is creating so weird jaggard lines/banding..

Here is another screenshot of another attempt.

This problem is really frustrating me. Any help would be appreciated!

This topic has been closed for replies.

2 replies

eliyah
Known Participant
April 4, 2021

wow finaly, for years i have been wondering about it with brushes. 16 bit maaan. did the fix. thanks a lot

jillm10076417
Participant
April 21, 2022

bahahahah me too!!!!!! 🤯 poooooof

Trevor.Dennis
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 12, 2019

Yes it is a problem.  Working in 16  bit will  help, but if you are painting in layer masks, then they are 8 bit regardless of the image bit depth.  Adding some noise (jitter) also helps, but that always feels like a poor solution to me when you are trying to get a super fine gradient.  I also tend to use Gaussian blur rather than a brush for large soft gradients.  Use a new layer, and make it a Smart object so you can go back in and fine tune.

But 16 bit will be the best way to go, and the slightest bit of noise.  Here again, with a Smart Object layer you can fine tune.  I like to use Camera RAW > fx > Grain.

This example has the original on the left, and Gaussian blur (150) plus fx > Grain (5, 20, 20) on the right.

Participant
March 12, 2019

Hi Trevor,

That has helped quite a lot, thank you.

I am not really sure what the purpose of the smart layer is though? Do you do the brushing/blurring/grain and then convert to smart layer?