Known Participant

Answered

Why can't Photoshop (and other editing software) edit images in the cloud?

Forum|Forum|9 years ago
February 1, 2017
7 replies
1480 views

Why is it that Photoshop, Lightroom etc. can't edit images that are directly stored on a drive in the cloud such as Google Drive, Sync.com etc.?

As it is, all my images are stored on an external hard drive attached to my computer and backed up to an online storage system (Sync.com)

If Photoshop etc. could edit images stored directly on the cloud then I wouldn't need the extra storage space attached directluy to my computer.

This topic has been closed for replies.

Correct answer Test Screen Name

The problem is that "cloud" is an idea rather than anything standard. Each cloud provider offers a different web site, different ways of working. You're absolutely right that we're going towards easy integration, but we aren't there yet. It's still anarchy. What you need to make sense of the anarchy is software that knows how to talk to each cloud provider (each in its own special way) and which can be used from your apps. The simplest idea is that your cloud storage gets a drive letter on Windows at least.

So there's software that does this for DropBox. For iCloud. Google Drive. For most, though some are secret and some just aren't suitable. A web search finds stuff but it would be better if people could recommend stuff. What is your specific favourite cloud?

Also, bear this in mind: if you really want stuff to go to the cloud, and be deleted from your computer: where is your backup??

Chuck Uebele

Community Expert

If it were even possible working with a file that's on the cloud and not on a local drive would be painfully slow.

R

Richard4911Author

Known Participant

I would suspect that it would depend on your Internet speed?

Chuck Uebele

Community Expert

It would have to be very fast. Even working over a connected network is slow.

T

Test Screen NameCorrect answer

Legend

The problem is that "cloud" is an idea rather than anything standard. Each cloud provider offers a different web site, different ways of working. You're absolutely right that we're going towards easy integration, but we aren't there yet. It's still anarchy. What you need to make sense of the anarchy is software that knows how to talk to each cloud provider (each in its own special way) and which can be used from your apps. The simplest idea is that your cloud storage gets a drive letter on Windows at least.

So there's software that does this for DropBox. For iCloud. Google Drive. For most, though some are secret and some just aren't suitable. A web search finds stuff but it would be better if people could recommend stuff. What is your specific favourite cloud?

Also, bear this in mind: if you really want stuff to go to the cloud, and be deleted from your computer: where is your backup??

T

Test Screen Name

Legend

So, you aren't willing to install the software you need. Ok.

R

Richard4911Author

Known Participant

Sorry to sound confused here, what software do I need?

T

Test Screen Name

Legend

Did you look into integrator software? It can't happen without software to make it happen. Of course at least the current working files must be on disk.

R

Richard4911Author

Known Participant

You would have thought that with the high use of the 'cloud' and the way technology is going that this would have been an easy thing to achieve; evidently not... shame... ;(

Ares Hovhannesyan

Community Expert

Usually I work with Creative Cloud Folder on my hard drive and then all files synchronized with my CC automatically. .

R

Richard4911Author

Known Participant

But the original files are still stored on your hard drive taking up space, yes?

This is what I want to avoid and with all the technology available and the use of the 'cloud' so prevelant surely this should be possible?

gener7

Community Expert

If your cloud storage has integration with your File Finder (Mac) or Explorer (PC), that should work.

Creative Cloud and Dropbox have this capability. In Photoshop just navigate to it, and check the Lightroom forum for instructions on their side.

R

Richard4911Author

Known Participant

Thank you; how do I navigate to a webpage address in Photoshop though?

I'f I'm using Dropbox or Google Drive all my image files are still on my hard drive whereas I want to be able to edit images that are stored on an online storage location without having them on my hard drive.

I don't think it's possible but have no idea as to why this feature (as far as I can tell) isn't available?