Skip to main content
Participant
August 19, 2022
Answered

Why no perceptual merging of layers?

  • August 19, 2022
  • 1 reply
  • 308 views

When I press Ctrl+E the default behaviour I want to see is a perceptual merge. I want to see the thing in front of me get merged with the thing below, with NO CHANGES.

 

[text edited by Moderator]

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Jeff Arola

If your not looking at the image at 100% (actual pixels) then your liable not to see the true results of the merge since photoshop uses interpolation at all views other than 100%.

1 reply

Jeff Arola
Community Expert
Jeff ArolaCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
August 19, 2022

If your not looking at the image at 100% (actual pixels) then your liable not to see the true results of the merge since photoshop uses interpolation at all views other than 100%.

Participant
August 20, 2022

Not at all what I'm talking about. Unless you merge layers carefully, Photoshop will never do it right. It will combine layer modes into garbage instead of collapsing the actual presentation of what you see in front of you on to the desired layer. There's no command key to make this happen, Screen on top of Vivid on top of Normal / etc? Merge the Screen and Vivid. Boom, Photoshop it wrong, the layers are merged with no intelligence. This catches every user off guard at some point, and it becomes a serious problem when you're 30 layers in and basically need to stamp the entire image and start over.

 

But look, twice now you deleted text because it made someone uncomfortable, and yet managed to get yourself two updoots? People have complained about this for ages and worked around it by avoiding layers. I'm surprised you didn't outright edit my response to suit your "whoosh" answer!

Participant
August 20, 2022

...and/or worked around it by collapsing the entire image. This has nothing to do with resolution / zoom.