red eye removal

[sarah_4393]

Make the red eye removal tool able to be done in an empty layer.

[Peru Bob]

If the layer is empty, what would the tool do?

[sarah_4393]

Make the edit non-destructive without requiring a background copy.

[sarah_4393]

The tool would require a setting for "sample all layers" similar to the healing brush or clone stamp.

[Claire H.]

Thanks so much for sharing your idea! If you’re open to it, adding a bit more detail can really help others understand the impact of your request. For example, like you stated, making the edit non-destructive?

Additionally, if you believe others may also benefit from this, please feel free to encourage them to upvote or share their thoughts in the comments. Thanks again for being part of the community! ^CH

[Stephen Marsh]

The tool would require a setting for "sample all layers" similar to the healing brush or clone stamp.

By @sarah_4393

OK, that would speed up copying just the eyes to a new layer, before using the tool. Non-destructive, but not in the general sense as defined by adjustment layers. Adjustment layers are designed for non-destructive use above pixel layers, but would need a mask.

[Stephen Marsh]

The tool would require a setting for "sample all layers" similar to the healing brush or clone stamp.

[lisa_9817]

When you add the layer. Sample layer below. 

[sarah_4393]

Sample layers below isn't an option either. 

[sarah_4393]

I teach Photoshop and we try to do everything nondestructively so we can always go back to the original. The red eye tool seems to be the only "retouching tool" that isn't able to be done in a new layer. It has to be done on a layer with pixel content, which means the background layer has to be duplicated. Tools like the healing brush and the clone stamp can be done in a new layer just by changing an option on the top bar to "sample all layers".