Image rejected

[roberto_pistelli]

Hello friends.
Can someone tell me why do you think this image was rejected?
I appreciate. Thanks.

[daniellei4510 · Accepted solution]

While the intricacies of the basket itself are well rendered, the banding or rings at the bottom and at the top with the lid is poorly rendered in comparison. They seem to appear and reappear in an unnatural manner. 

[Jill_C · Accepted solution]

There are some drawing issues - here's one:

[roberto_pistelli]

Wow! How the hell I didn't see that! lol. Many Thanks.

[Jill_C]

I am impressed that AI was able to generate such an intricate design on the sides and top of the basket.

[daniellei4510]

I was assuming it was 3D rendered, but if not, I'm impressed in either case.

[roberto_pistelli]

Its not AI. It's a 3D render. I'm fixing it and I'm going to post it back.

[Abambo]

You will have countless intersections(1) to fix. But you also need to fix the render quality(2), like the shadow noise here and the white border at the shadow area.

[roberto_pistelli]

The white border is the reflex of the plane where it's on.

[Abambo]

The white border is the reflex of the plane where it's on.

By @roberto_pistelli

It looks like an error… but I've seen on your second try what you mean. I probably concentrated on the wrong place for that error, because of the crop I used, to show the issues.

[roberto_pistelli]

What do you guys think now?

[Abambo]

The shadow is still grainy, and you still have intersections. Once you have identified the possible errors, you should really be able to check them yourself. 

[Nancy OShea]

Something's visually off here. Your basket appears to have no anterior walls.  I can see light through the lid which shouldn't be possible. 

By way of comparison, this 'woven basket with lid' from Adobe Stock's basket inventory is more realistic. No background can be seen through the lid.

The devil's in the details. 😊

Hope that helps.

[roberto_pistelli]

Hi! Thanks for response. I saw the link you shared, but those are all
wicker basket. I have this real one in my home and it's made of wire, so
you can see through it. It's not so tight like a wicker one.

[Nancy OShea]

You asked for feedback and I gave you my perspective. Light behaves differently when traveling through one, two or more layers of mesh and shadows. That's basic light theory.

Good luck.

[roberto_pistelli]

I appreciate your comment. Gonna work on it. Many thanks!

[jacquelingphoto2017]

Hi @roberto_pistelli,

There are some compression noise around the edge of the basket and is most obvious at the top of the lid.

Also it is unnatural that one would be seeing the background so clearly through an enclosed basket. If we were to assume that the inside of the basket is white, this should be consistent throughout the entire picture.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

[roberto_pistelli]

Thanks Jacquelin. I gave up of this image. Have a nice weekend.

[jacquelingphoto2017]

You are welcome @roberto_pistelli. You too have a pleasant day.

Best wishes

Jacquelin