Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
As well as technicakl issues, did you have property releases for all of these? They are all someone's intellectual property, and some even have trademarks!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
If you take a photograph of anything made by another person, which they could recognise, you need their written permission. Otherwise the picture cannot be used commercially.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
No, the rights not belong to you. You cannot sell them on Adobe Stock. Understanding this is vital to every commercial photographer. It applies to EVERYTHING man made: cars, clothes, buildings, gifts, everything even if you don't know who made it. Perhaps I can explain it this way.
Suppose you took a great picture of some clouds. You make a birthday card with it, and give it to a friend. Now the friend takes a photo of the card, and sells it on Adobe Stock.
Do they own their photo of your card? Sure. Do they own the card? Sure.
Are then allowed to sell their photo of the card on Adobe Stock? NO, because you own the original work. YOU have the property rights.
In the same way, let's look at the photo of Actrapid.
Do you own the photo of Actrapid? Sure. Do you own the vial of Actrapid? Sure.
Are you allowed to sell your photo of Actrapid on Adobe Stock? No, because someone else owns the original work. THEY have the property rights.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hello,
Apart from the IP issue, I think the shadow behind the items is also causing problems - this is a technical issue. If you were to fix this, then the next issue would be IP!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Sure, if you fix the shadow you can upload the image, and you can check whether we were right that most will be rejected because of IP. Did you read a word I wrote? Apparently not.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
What is IP? Is this mean issued with the copyright? Or ip address? Please explain...thanks
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
IP - intellectual property. Copyright, trademarks, and more. Please read what I wrote carefully and IF YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND IT PLEASE SAY SO. I went to a lot of trouble to try to explain this in a way which makes sense to new photographers not used to the need for IP releases on commercial work. And especially why your statement "the items in the images belongs to me" is not relevant. I wrote:
No, the rights not belong to you. You cannot sell them on Adobe Stock. Understanding this is vital to every commercial photographer. It applies to EVERYTHING man made: cars, clothes, buildings, gifts, everything even if you don't know who made it. Perhaps I can explain it this way.
Suppose you took a great picture of some clouds. You make a birthday card with it, and give it to a friend. Now the friend takes a photo of the card, and sells it on Adobe Stock.
Do they own their photo of your card? Sure. Do they own the card? Sure.
Are then allowed to sell their photo of the card on Adobe Stock? NO, because you own the original work. YOU have the property rights.
In the same way, let's look at the photo of Actrapid.
Do you own the photo of Actrapid? Sure. Do you own the vial of Actrapid? Sure.
Are you allowed to sell your photo of Actrapid on Adobe Stock? No, because someone else owns the original work. THEY have the property rights.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The medicine, product label and packaging was made by someone other than you. Is that correct?
You are infringing on their IP (intellectual property) rights. Your picture of that object cannot be sold commercially without signed permission from the legal owner of that product.
Does that make more sense now?