Please help me understand the rejection for technical reasons

[evgenyd14458540]

This is not noise (because image edited by denoised effect and shoot on 100 iso), this is not camera shake, motion blur or focus issue - because camera on tripod and focus is fully defocused specially. 

[ricky336 · Accepted solution]

Hello,

To state the obvious, it is out of focus, despite it being intentional. Adobe will just refuse it.

[evgenyd14458540]

))))) all bokeh lights is defocused zone of image ! Because Bokeh - is defocused part of image. This is Physics
And then I ask - how do other images with intentionally blurred backgrounds and garland lights get on sale ?

[ricky336 · Accepted solution]

So, as from the examples you posted, you have a long way to go to match their quality.

[evgenyd14458540]

And what wrong with my quality ? 😂
This is 24 Mp shoot with lowes iso 100 and Uncomressed Sony A7 RAW files converted in LR CC
The edited is very accuratly and color range don't out of the sRGB color range without color clipping in all channels.

[Abambo]

And what wrong with my quality ? 😂
This is 24 Mp shoot with lowes iso 100 and Uncomressed Sony A7 RAW files converted in LR CC
The edited is very accuratly and color range don't out of the sRGB color range without color clipping in all channels.

By @evgenyd14458540

@ricky336 told you: it's out of focus. The rest of the editing can be as good as it can be.

[ricky336]

Quality meaning composition, aesthetics... etc.

The bokeh isn't good here. You haven't used it effectively - sorry!

[evgenyd14458540]

In the MY original example I have provided, I see a very mediocre quality. I have been on the Stocks for more than 6 years and understand what quality is. I have been in photography for more than 11-12 years. In these specific photos there is no noise, no overexposure, no banding, have good compositio and etc

[evgenyd14458540]

https://stock.adobe.com/ru/search/images?load_type=search&is_recent_search=&search_type=usertyped&k=... 

[Abambo]

Despite the fact that some of your search results are illustrations (vector graphics), it is highly probable that most of those pictures would get refused today if submitted today. That's the way it is.

[evgenyd14458540]

Try to upload it tomorrow...
Probably the inspectors are not in a good mood

[Abambo]

Out of focus, obviously...

[evgenyd14458540]

How can be BOKEH in focus ? This is - physics.
I speccially shoot defocused background lights

[Abambo]

Instead of discussing the obvious, take my advice: move on, it won't be accepted.

[evgenyd14458540]

Like this image
https://stock.adobe.com/ru/search/images?filters%5Bcontent_type%3Aphoto%5D=1&filters%5Bcontent_type%...

[evgenyd14458540]

Out of 10 Main Stocks, only Adobe did not understand this image and rejected it 🤦🏻‍:male_sign:

[Abambo]

It is Adobe's right to refuse the image if it does not fit in the database. Be happy that those 9 other stock providers did accept the image.