They rejected my images made with artificial intelligence of ecological themes.

[thisisepiko]

I sent a group of images with this same concept and they were all rejected. They fulfill the commercial function and in terms of quality it is not inferior to other images that have been approved for me. I would like to know a specific reason why this large group of images was rejected.

 

  

[thisisepiko]

Hi Adobe Stock team,

I'm writing to inquire about the recent rejection of my submitted images. I'm eager to understand the specific reasons behind the rejection so I can improve my future submissions.

Could you please provide me with more detailed feedback on the images that were not accepted? Knowing what areas need improvement will help me create content that meets your guidelines.

Thank you for your time and assistance.

Sincerely, Luis Romero from épiko.

[Jill_C]

You are not addressing Adobe directly in this forum and will receive no reply from an Adobe employee here. This is a user-to-user forum. The tiny images are too small to evaluate properly; however I do see a drawing error as shown below.

[daniellei4510]

Whale: one stripe does not go all the way to the end like the others do.

Was the stop image submitted as a single asset? If single, we can not tell much from these small assets.

[thisisepiko]

Thank you for your feedback on my submission. I'll be sure to pay closer attention to the details of my images moving forward. 

The images that appear as several small boxes were sent individually. It is a reference to know if something is wrong in the style of the photos.

[Abambo]

They fulfill the commercial function and in terms of quality it is not inferior to other images that have been approved for me.

  

By @thisisepiko

Let me put it like this: if you have the same errors in your accepted assets than you have in these, they were wrongfully accepted. That is a real problem as the stock database is flooded with bad assets because some moderators do not or cannot do their job correctly. 

For the whale: you have visible compression artefacts all around the picture, especially in the white lines. 

In the background texture you also have occasionally "dust" particles that could be cleaned up. Generally speaking the asset would have more value for the buyer, if it would be a PNG file fith a transparent background. 

The thermometer has about the same issues:

In addition you have rendering errors in both assets.

The assets as such are OK with some commercial value, but the issues in the files do make them unusable for most applications. 

What I would do: I would add transparency to the background, correct the compression artefacts and rendering errors, make them smaller (that will make disapear the rest of the errors) and group them together in one or two files. That will create nice environmental icons. You won't make that much, as a buyer would need only to licence one or two images for getting an icon collection of the same style, but as the assets would be much more useful, I think that you could offset that with a good number of sales. 

Personally, I would probably have done this in Photoshop or even Illustrator. It would have taken more time to create, but it would be error free and much easier to cut out. And as soon as you have create the necessary custom brushes, you could expand the collection easily.

[thisisepiko]

Thank you so much for your detailed feedback on the assets. I truly appreciate you taking the time to analyze them and provide such constructive criticism.

Your insights are invaluable. I understand the limitations of the current state of the assets and agree that the issues you've pointed out significantly impact their usability.

I'm already working on implementing your suggestions:

Adding transparency: This will definitely enhance their versatility and make them more suitable for various applications.

Correcting compression artifacts and rendering errors: This is crucial for ensuring high-quality visuals.

Grouping assets: This will make them more organized and user-friendly.

While the initial investment of time may be higher, I believe that by addressing these issues, we can significantly increase the value and marketability of the assets. This will ultimately lead to a higher volume of sales, offsetting the initial effort.

Thank you again for your valuable feedback and support. I'm confident that with these improvements, we can create a truly exceptional collection of environmental icons.

[Abambo]

You're welcome.