Hi @Rikk Flohr: Photography. I've recently upgraded to Lightroom Classic 11.1 and I'm reasonably certain the R5 colour noise handling bug has been corrected. All of a sudden, I notice that images that previously needed to have the colour noise reduction slider set to 5 now show colour noise, and I need to increase the slider to 25 to get an acceptable result.   Are you able to confirm that the bug has been fixed? Nothing in the release notes mentions this.   While I'm very pleased that the bug appears to have been fixed, it also creates rework, because I now need to go back and return the colour noise slider for all of my R5 images from 5 to 25. Really, this is a "breaking change" and should have been properly documented. It took me a while to realise something wasn't right when images at middling ISOs (1000+) started to show colour noise when I wasn't expecting it.   Thanks,   Nick ... View more

Thanks Todd. Hi @Rikk I also just tried the same thing in ACR and found exactly the same behaviour. A setting of 5 with the Canon R5 looks similar to a setting of 25 with the Nikon Z7II. For completeness, I'm using Lightroom Classic. I haven't tried Lightroom cloud. ... View more

@Rikk Hi - I have updated Lightroom to the latest release (v10.4) and it has made absolutely no difference to this issue. Can you please acknowledge the issue and that it has been added to a bug tracker somewhere? Thanks, Nick  ... View more

@Rikk will do Rikk. Are there any bug fix release notes for Lightroom Classic? ... View more

@bill_3305731 you've hit the nail on the head but completely back to front. If you look at the DPR images as is, you would conclude that there is something wrong with the camera - as you did. But in fact, the problem is with Lightroom. You can see the horrible colour smearing in the right hand image - looks like a terrible camera. But if you quickly jump into the develop module for the right hand image and wind the colour noise slider down to 5, you'll see that the colour smearing suddenly disappears. If you then try the same thing with another camera (eg the Nikon Z7II), you'll find that the same colour smearing effect can be replicated by turning the colour noise slider up to 100. In other words, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the camera. Lightroom, on the other hand is mangling the R5 image in a way that it doesn't for any other similar camera. I really hope this is clear and we can focus on getting the point across to Adobe so that they can actually fix it. ... View more

People, can we get back on topic please? There is no question that there is a bug in Lightroom affecting the R5. You don't have to believe me: DPR found the same thing when they tested the R5 - see this example from their exposure latitude test (using Lightroom as the RAW processor): https://www.dpreview.com/reviews/image-comparison/fullscreen?attr144_0=canon_eosr5&attr144_1=sony_a7riv&attr144_2=nikon_z7&attr144_3=panasonic_dcs1r&attr146_0=100_5&attr146_1=100_5&attr146_2=100_5&attr146_3=100_5&attr177_0=efc&attr177_1=efc&attr177_2=efc&attr177_3=efc&normalization=full&widget=784&x=-0.344412222082125&y=0.1654458798444751 I'd love to hear from Team Adobe: has this bug been captured and are you working on it? This seems to be the only way I can report a bug to you. ... View more

Bill, I don't think we're on the same page. No it's not the video card, and no it's not plugins. It's a bug. We're not looking for colour noise, we're looking for the colour getting smeared in specific places, caused by an incorrect handling of the colour noise slider. Did you read what I wrote over at DPR? Have you seen the multiple voices agreeing with my observations? ... View more

I'm using Mac, but I doubt that's relevant. Have you tried using images that are either high in ISO or low in ISO pushed in exposure? Try downloading the RAW images from DPReview as I have - see the link I provided. ... View more

Same here (not on big sur yet). Ok it's a first world problem but not a good look for a company who specialises in graphic design.  ... View more

Same here - this drives me nuts. Has been an intermittent issue for as long as I can remember. When will it be fixed? ... View more

This drives me mad when it happens - I can't believe it hasn't been fixed yet. Adobe takes my money every month, but leaves issues like this neglected for years. It isn't good enough ... View more

We use an NTLM based corporate proxy, but I have always had problems with Adobe products in talking directly to our corporate proxy. So I have a CNTLM setup, which presents a simple local open proxy to applications on my Mac while handling NTLM authentication back to the corporate proxy directly. The thing to note is that every other Adobe CC product works absolutely fine with my setup. The screen you provided showed up just once when I had to first inform CC of my CNTLM setup, and that's it - all CC products worked seamlessly thereafter. But not Lightroom CC. It just flat out doesn't work. It also doesn't challenge me for proxy information / passwords. It just says "Network Disconnected". Oh, and the corporate proxy operates on 8080. CNTLM is able to translate port 80 on the application side to 8080 on the proxy side. ... View more

Yes please - touch bar support for Lightroom is essential!! So much that could be done. When can we expect it? ... View more

Same problem here - glad to see it's not just me - but keen to see a fix! ... View more

Me too - please! ... View more

Totally agree with everyone here. Lightroom books must have the ability to create borders. I much prefer the Lightroom book module to iPhoto, but this one difference makes lightroom much the worse for book making. Please include it in LR6! ... View more