Adobe Font not displaying correctly in After Effects

Barteldes Small is from Adobe Fonts, it displays correctly in other Adobe programs but not in After Effects.  Here is what it is supposed to look like in Illustrator:

Here is what it looks like in After Effects:

It looks like only the capitatal letters are being effected. I hav tried removing and readding the font family back again, and I do not have any other fonts named Barteldes on my computer, also it is an Adobe font.  Not sure why this is happening.

Thanks!