Skip to main content
Dierenwinkel Doc
Dierenwinkel Doc
Inspiring
October 27, 2022

Position sepperating dimentions dragging bug

  • October 27, 2022
  • 3 replies
  • 405 views

Hi currently when you have 2 layers,
 - 1 layer with Sepperate position dimentions
 - 1 layer without Sepperate position dimentions 
Now select both layers & drag the position (with the numbers). It doesnt update both of them if you select the one with sepperate dimentions. The other way around works.

 

See video for a detailed example.

 

Much love,

 

Dierenwinkel

This topic has been closed for replies.

3 replies

JohnColombo17100380
Community Manager
JohnColombo17100380Community Manager
Community Manager
November 29, 2022

Hi @Dierenwinkel Doc,

Thank you for reporting this issue. I do agree with @Rick Gerard that is working as designed; the separated Position properties are "children" of the combined Position property under the hood, and so changes flow "down" when the Position is changed, but not back up when the separated X/Y/Z are changed.

 

That said, I think this would be better handled as a bug rather than as a feature request, so I'll be opening a ticket on our side to address this behavior in a future release.

 

Thanks again,

- John, After Effects Engineering Team 

    R
    Community Expert
    Rick GerardCommunity Expert
    Community Expert
    October 27, 2022

    The behavior you see makes sense because Position is a three-value (x, y, z) array until you separate dimensions. Separated dimensions, rotation, and opacity are not arrays. You need to use an expression if you want a multi-value property to drive one of the values of a single-value property.  On the other hand, once separated, X, Y, and Z position values are still Position properties, so they should drive the corresponding value in the Position array. 

     

    You could make it a feature request. I don't see it as a bug. 

     

    I rarely separate dimensions for Position. It is far easier and more efficient to control the motion path of a layer using the pen tool in the Composition Panel and the timing with a Speed Graph than trying to make complex movements by animating the X, Y, and Z position values.

     

     

    Dierenwinkel Doc
    Dierenwinkel DocAuthor
    Inspiring
    October 27, 2022

    Forgot to add when you do it the other way around it also creates 2 keyframes even if you only moved 1 position (example Just the Y position). 

     

    M1 Max, AE 23.0.0

    Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
    Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices