Skip to main content
roiyn17187271
Participant
March 12, 2023

Prores Color Bending & Other Problems

  • March 12, 2023
  • 4 replies
  • 774 views

Hi, I'm Having the following problems with QT Prores files in AE 23 M1 Studio Mac:

Color bending in Prores 4444 

Slightly less color bending, but still lots of it, in Prores 422HQ

 

These problems do NOT accure when opening the same clips on a different app like Davinci Resolve.

(I am workin in 32bit color space)

 

Also:

Slight Color shift (towards green) when rendering Prores 4444 from AE

And instability in color when using Proxy mode on Prores 4444 files (color shifts every few frames)

 

 

Does anybody els have these problems?

 

 

 

4 replies

roiyn17187271
Participant
March 12, 2023

Thanks for this tip as well. I would have never thought of rechecking this checkbox on the next update (and i've been updating alot recently, due to the istability of AE with the M1).

Anyway - you have proven to be a very helpfull dude indeed. 

thanks alot

R

Thaumar
Inspiring
March 12, 2023

Oh interesting! So disabling the hardware acceleration also fixed the banding problem. 
Hmmm, seems Adobes implementation of the M1 hardware acceleration is even more broken than I thought if it also introduces banding. 
Fortunately it's easily turned off, but be aware, whenever you update After Effects (or sometimes after a major crash) this setting will return to the default ON state.
It's a shame Adobe thinks this problem is not serious enough to default this setting to OFF instead of ON and it's even one of the few (if not the only) setting that is not migrated when updating after effects. You know, that one setting they know is broken, that's the one they will default to and force upon you every time you update.
This problem is clearly not very high on the priority list. 

roiyn17187271
Participant
March 12, 2023

OMG , Disabling hardware acceleration in the import preference pane DID solve the problem!

It also solved the  'banding' (gradiants showing bands with hard edges) problem

Man,  that was the single most usfull advice i got in a long time....

Thank you so much!

Much respect

R

Thaumar
Inspiring
March 12, 2023

Yes, the green flickering is a known problem om m1 macs using Adobe software. Disabling hardware acceleration in the import preference pane will solve that problem.

As for color 'bending' I'm not sure what that means.

If you are talking about color 'banding' (gradiants showing bands with hard edges) than the problem might be in the output settings: when rendering on 16 or 32 bit, make sure the output settings match the color depth. For prores you should make sure the output color depth is set to trillons, not millions. For other output you can also select floating point (EXR for example). Make sure to edit your presets/templates to match the color depth of the codec. 
If with 'bending' you mean there is a gamma shift going on when rendering ProRes you might want to check your footage interpretation color settings tab and make sure they are the same in the output color settings tab. Make sure they both have the same color profile selected. 
Hope any of these suggestions are useful for solving your problems...