Skip to main content
Participant
Nov 21, 2026 5:11 PM UTC
Open for Voting

Mask overlay remains visible when turned off.

Adobe Lightroom Desktop 10.0 — Mask Overlay and Adjustment Bugs

Report date: November 21, 2026
Application: Adobe Lightroom Desktop 10.0 (not Lightroom Classic)
Operating system: Windows 11
Workflow: Lightroom Local mode, editing JPEG photographs

Issue 1 — Mask overlay remains visible when Show Overlay is OFF

Problem: The red mask overlay continues to appear on the photograph even when the Show Overlay control is switched off.

This behavior has occurred repeatedly while editing photographs in Lightroom Desktop 10.0.

Most recent example: November 21, 2026

  • Photograph: DSC_0692.JPG

  • Camera: Nikon Z5

  • Lens: NIKKOR Z 28–400mm

  • Mask type: Select Subject

  • Subjects: Multiple bison in a grassy field

  • Show Overlay: OFF

  • Actual result: Red overlay remains visible on the selected bison

  • Expected result: Red overlay disappears when Show Overlay is switched off

The attached screenshot clearly demonstrates the problem. The Show Overlay toggle is off, but the red overlay remains visible across the selected subjects.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Open a JPEG photograph in Lightroom Desktop 10.0 using Local mode.

  2. Open the Masking panel.

  3. Create a new mask using Select Subject.

  4. Turn Show Overlay off.

  5. Observe whether the red mask overlay disappears.

Frequency: Intermittent but recurring.

Issue 2 — Unexpected visual changes when applying or modifying masks

We have also encountered unexpected behavior while editing Yellowstone thermal-feature photographs.

In one example, separate masks were created for vegetation and a thermal pool.

Observed behavior:

  • Adjustments to the vegetation mask appeared to change portions of the thermal pool.

  • The affected pool areas were not visibly included in the vegetation mask overlay.

  • Enabling the pool mask produced unexpected changes in the pool's appearance.

  • Disabling the mask restored the previous appearance.

  • Attempts to subtract overlapping areas did not consistently resolve the problem.

  • Deleting the vegetation mask helped recover the intended appearance.

This raises concerns about the relationship between displayed mask boundaries and the actual application of adjustments.

We cannot yet determine whether this is a mask-selection issue, an adjustment-processing issue, or a display-refresh problem.

Issue 3 — Mask adjustment values and preset behavior

We have observed instances where newly created masks contain adjustment values associated with previously applied settings or presets.

We would like clarification regarding the intended behavior when creating a new mask after applying a preset.

In particular, we want to establish whether mask adjustment values are being retained unexpectedly or whether this is normal preset behavior.

Impact on editing

These issues interfere with selective editing because the displayed mask state cannot always be trusted.

When the overlay remains visible despite being switched off, it becomes difficult to evaluate the actual photographic result.

Unexpected changes outside visibly selected mask areas also make it difficult to maintain consistent exposure, color, and tonal balance.

Requested action

Please investigate these behaviors in Lightroom Desktop 10.0 for Windows 11, particularly in Local mode.

We would appreciate confirmation of whether these are known issues, whether workarounds are available, and whether fixes are planned for an upcoming update.

Supporting evidence: Screenshot captured November 21, 2026, showing DSC_0692.JPG with the red Select Subject overlay visible while Show Overlay is OFF.