Participant

P: Generated images violate user guidelines

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
May 23, 2023
1085 replies
307313 views

So as you can see, it's a PG-13 relatively inoffensive image of a woman in a bunny outfit. The top worked fine, and I was able to complete the top ear, which is cool. When I tried to extend the bottom with generative fill, though, I got this warning. They're just a pair of legs wearing stockings, and I wanted to extend it.

It feels like a false flag - though I could be wrong? I find myself thinking it would do the same for women in swimsuits.

Figured I'd share here.

Show previous replies

J

johnb60867848

Participating Frequently

I am constantly struggling with the "violate user guidelines" warning. It seems like its a random hit/miss thing. The warning is too vague. The warning should give more information to say how the guidelines were violated

J

johnb60867848

Participating Frequently

I tried replacing shoes on a model. When I enter "Slingbacks" I get the warning every time. If I enter "High heels" I get a warning most of the time. If I enter "Stiletto" It usually works. Very strange

daniellei4510

Community Expert

Well remember...it's a beta. While it has happened on random objects at times, it seems to happen most often when skin is involved (hiding mangled hands or feet, for example, or covering up an arm. It's not US doing the guideline violations...it's the bot tied to very extreme constraints. And it's difficult to report the issue, since the violating images aren't shown to us, in order to give the result a thumbs up/down/report or describe the issue.

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.

I

IAmZiyah

Participant

When Using the Generative Fill Option on skin, in areas such as elbows and sometimes shoulders "go agaist community guidelines". It makes no sense and seems like a bug.

Z

zevendesign18164115

Known Participant

Even without a prompt, I am getting violation errors. The image is of a little girl with yellow balloons. The prompt is empty. I am trying to get rid of some graphics printed on the balloons. I've successfully used the tool on this exact image many times, but now it keeps erroring when I try.

S

SDS1962

Participant

I too keep getting random "Violates user guidelines" errors when trying to expand the edges of photos. This happens even when there is nothing in the photo but scenery! Is there any way to report these errors to Adobe?

Graham24508943nobd

Known Participant

When you generate, a green box appears at the top of your workspace. Press
the thumbs down and tell them what's gone wrong

paulg66021388

Known Participant

So I just decided to try generative Ai for the first time and I wanted it to remove an ugly grey section of wall in the photo and hopefully extend the wall and floor tiles to fill that section. I don't know what's it's coming up with that is violating user guidelines but I haven't typed anything into the box and I wouldn't have thought there was anything offensive in my photo!

PS version 24.6.0 on Windows 11

Graham24508943nobd

Known Participant

Finally got mine working. Impressed with generating woodland & grass, but oh dear, animals & birds are way too large and artifical looking at the moment

J

jessep83494163

Participant

I'm testing the beta version of the Content-Aware Fill tool. When I tried to use the tool on a picture of a flower (an image I own), the system flagged it and stopped the action, pointing me to the Adobe Generative AI Beta User Guidelines.

I don't believe I'm violating any of the rules. Could you help me understand why this is happening and how to fix it?

Thank you,

Jesse

stevenjr2008

Participant

I am getting a false posive for violating community guidline for "Large elk with larg antlers".

The error keeps saying "The image was removed becuase it viloates use guidlines"

I can use the same selection with "A cow" and it works, but "Large elk with larg antlers" triggers it.

Matias Larhag

Participant

These violate conflicts has to be updated, when you can´t even remove a background detail with generative fill.

CShubert

Community Manager

Curious what happens @Matias Larhag if you expand you selection, not so tight to the subjects in the background, do you still get the error? Testing on your image we were able to get three options with the third looking the best.

T

tomf35092362

Participating Frequently

the generated images were removed because they violate the user guidelines when i use generitive fii in photoshop beta.the images are of ladies playing football