Skip to main content
H
Hematita
Participant
May 23, 2023

P: Generated images violate user guidelines

 

So as you can see, it's a PG-13 relatively inoffensive image of a woman in a bunny outfit. The top worked fine, and I was able to complete the top ear, which is cool. When I tried to extend the bottom with generative fill, though, I got this warning. They're just a pair of legs wearing stockings, and I wanted to extend it.

It feels like a false flag - though I could be wrong? I find myself thinking it would do the same for women in swimsuits.

Figured I'd share here.

    1084 replies

    Show previous replies
    Graham24508943nobd
    Graham24508943nobd
    Known Participant
    August 23, 2023

    I've tried a few including mid journey and stable diffusion. Mid journey humans are far better, but, IMO adobe AI generated one have a far more natural look. Even stable diffusion have some terribly distorted  limbs & faces.

      E
      Encartauk
      Known Participant
      August 23, 2023

      I've not used any other AI art 'generators' apart from trying a few free web-based ones and Bing AI chat. I have seen results in other programs like Stable Diffusion and questioned the quality of PS results myself - but I was thinking, do any of those other programs allow users to select areas of images and generate areas based off text prompts and/or just AI's assessment if left blank?

      I assumed that in the others that if the user wants to change things they have to do it all by text prompts without selecting certain areas that they want modifying first e.g. 'move right arm above head, change dress to red, replace shoes with sneakers' etc.

      Also, do any of them allow to work in layers where you can mix things up and then chop and change easily during the process? And/or incorporate your own images, real or AI?

      So, I'm not stanning for Adobe here, but coming from a place myself where I've realised that Adobe and PS may have a unique tool here - but I could be wrong, which is why I'm asking.

        G
        Gaspar30
        Participating Frequently
        August 23, 2023

        I can not remember a time in the last 5 years that I was more frustarted than I have been in the last few weeks trying to use the Generative Fill tool in Photoshop. Every second thing I try gives the "violates terms and conditions" message when I can easily do the exact same prompts and keywords in other platforms (for example MidJourney). Here are a couple of examples:

        1. I have a young family friend who loves all things military and army related so I was doing up a cool poster of him dressed in military uniform with a cool epic battle scene behind him (rubble, military tanks, explosions, etc.) In the end I gave up and just put him against a bunch of trees in the background because I was ready to pull my hair out with (cursing removed) Photoshop!!! Every single word I tried was banned (tank,military, historical military vehicles, war scene, etc.)

        2. I was making a funny photo, sort of like a meme, with 2 groups of teachers fighting in a classroom (like a battle scene) and every (cursing removed) prompt I tried failed, even things like (destruction, hole in wall, fire, explosion, damaged building, etc.)

        Adobe, for the love!!! get your stupid act together and figure out how to moderate prompts properly!!! AARGGGHHH! When MidJourney thinks you've prompted something inapporpriate it actually lets you send the prompt to 2nd tier moderation bot and further checks it for problems. 95% of the time the prompt then gets through with no further problems.

         

        SOOOO FRUSTRATED! 😞

          J
          Jiri31574162k5gw
          Participating Frequently
          August 23, 2023

          I am under the impression that the generative filler feature is only for children between the ages of 4 and 12. I really don't understand this completely nonsensical restriction by Adobe. I have experienced that sometimes just typing a dot instead of a prompt will generate the fill.

            Z
            zvi_t
            Known Participant
            August 22, 2023

            Prompt "3+1=4 written in the sand" violated user guidelines. I'm so sorry Adobe, I didn't see anywhere in the guidelines that we can't generate letters in sand.

              J
              J-D-F
              Known Participant
              August 22, 2023

              add a "." to fix it! Or better yet, use a different Ai. Adobe is desperately trying to get ahead of the curve and has started too late. Even if they fail to be decent at creating a photography ai tool, they will still charge the same amount of money. They don't listen to complaints particularly well and rely on Adobe Stans to defend them in support groups. Bugs, broken tools and crashy releases for months or years have become the norm. 

                J
                Jarosław31803479xwxc
                Participant
                August 22, 2023

                Genereally, AI in Photoshop Beta is ok, but only sometimes and only for some type of users. For fine art nude photographers it is completely useless and iritating. Edward Weston, Alfred Stieglietz, Bill Brandt and a crowd of other fine art nude masters, whose work appears on the first page of any textbook for freshmen at any art acadamy, would never had a chance to use this feature - as they would violate Adobe's user guidelines. 

                  Kevin Stohlmeyer
                  Community Expert
                  Kevin StohlmeyerCommunity Expert
                  Community Expert
                  August 22, 2023

                  @Dan31823407zt64 please read the thread - enter a prompt, even a period to avoid the error.

                    D
                    Dan31823407zt64
                    Participant
                    August 22, 2023

                    First time I am using Generative fill in photoshot beta (25.0.0).  I am trying to fill a dark section of a wall and hoping it will lighten the wall.  I get an error that I am violating guidelines 

                      Graham24508943nobd
                      Graham24508943nobd
                      Known Participant
                      August 22, 2023

                      I got that simply trying to remove trees earlier 😢😥

                        Graham24508943nobd
                        Graham24508943nobd
                        Known Participant
                        August 22, 2023

                        I've founds prompting for swimming costume nearly always works, even bikinis pop up frequently

                          Show more replies
                          Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
                          Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices