Skip to main content
Inspiring
April 2, 2011

P: Cropping a Smart Layer causes Pixel Column Repeating

  • April 2, 2011
  • 14 replies
  • 913 views

When re-cropping a Smart Layer, saving and then seeing the updated smart layer on the master document, some pixel - column repeating occurs.


Image is not available



I've been aware of this issue for years, but I never knew where to speak up about it until now.

This topic has been closed for replies.

14 replies

Inspiring
April 3, 2011
Thanks for your reply Jeffrey. I've been using Photoshop for over 10 years now, so I'm more than happy to help any way I can.
Legend
April 3, 2011
Thanks. I'll have someone investigate. Is it alright if an engineer or quality engineer contacts you directly if they have any questions?
Inspiring
April 2, 2011

Image is not available



(Click above to download the PSD)

So it seems that the pixel repeating happen when shrinking the smart layer down to the size of the object. I've noticed Photoshop leaves space around the object by default when turning it into a Smart Layer. When you go in and try to optimize, it repeats the pixels, but when you crop up, meaning making the destination Smart Layer larger, it actually cuts off a pixel column.

I believe I've only seen this problem affect the images horizontally.
Not a huge deal, you can always drag the destination back to the master file, but it can become a problem when editing a Smart Layer that is instanced multiple times in the master.
Legend
April 2, 2011
Can you post the PSD that exhibits this behavior?