Known Participant

Investigating

P: Photoshop 27.10: "Edit in Photoshop" from Lightroom Classic & Lightroom Desktop does not load image with Denoise

345 replies
5228 views
Translate

Since today’s Photoshop 27.10 update, the “Edit in Photoshop” command in Lightroom Classic 15.5.1 is not working anymore for me. Photoshop opens automatically as before (if it’s not open yet) but no image is being loaded. Downgrading Photoshop to 27.9.1 resolves the issue and the “Edit in Photoshop” functionality is back to normal. I also tried to change the external editing file format from TIFF to PSD or PSB but this didn’t make any difference. Anyone else facing the same issue?

I’m running macOS Tahoe 26.6.2. Closing and re-opening LRC and PS didn’t solve the problem, rebooting the machine also didn’t show any effect.

P.S.: I posted this in the Photoshop forum as well

Pinned Reply By Sameer K

Hi everyone,

Thank you for the detailed reports and reproductions here. It has been really helpful in isolating the issue quickly. I’ve filed this for the engineering teamto investigate and prioritize.

In the meantime, here are confirmed workarounds:

Downgrade to Photoshop 27.9.1 via the Creative Cloud app (Other versions > 27.9.1).
Alternatively: Temporarily disable Denoise in Lightroom Classic before sending to Photoshop, then re-apply back in Lightroom, or it using Camera Raw as a filter inside Photoshop.

We understand this disrupts a core editing workflow and appreciate your patience. We'll update this thread as we have more information.

View reply

Show previous replies

JohanElzenga

Community Expert

Perhaps this has nothing to do with your drive, but with denoising. Maybe you tried a denoised image from the WD drive, and a not-denoised image from the older drive? This Photoshop problem is a known issue:

https://community.adobe.com/bug-reports-711/p-photoshop-27-10-edit-in-photoshop-from-lightroom-classic-does-not-load-image-1639250?tid=1639250&postid=7745403

Translate

-- Johan W. Elzenga

gary_sc

Community Expert

A few quick questions:

What is your OS and what release?

Have you given the new WD Passport permssion from your OS?

Does your LRC know about the new HD? What I mean by this, how did you get LRC content onto the new drive?

Let me provide a video that goes to the heart of this question PLEASE NOTE: There is some sort of squabble between YouTube and these forums. Below is a link, copy the full link and paste it into something where you can remove the space between “…you & tube…”

https://www.you tube.com/watch?v=_9B0lq6GJZc

Let us know…

Translate

T

TH1NOR3415930478zi

Participant

Nah don’t think tats it.
copy to external then import into orc.
should not be different on one from another. Thanks.

Translate

T

TH1NOR3415930478zi

Participant

So been using wd passports for some time no issue.

The last one after finishing edit in lrc, i go to the “edit in ps” option.

ps opens but not the images.

gone back to old drives to test and it workes.

So guessing it is something with permissions or bug on the new one….?

Anyone experienced this?

Translate

F

felixr67721244

Participant

Photoshop 27.10.0 do not open images from Lightroom

Translate

Ged_Traynor

Community Expert

@corrier3622488 you’re not alone, you can try the workarounds mentioned in the pinned post here

Translate

C

corrier3622488

Participant

When I choose to edit a photo in photoshop, it opens photoshop but does not open the photo.

Translate

guidostefanelli77

Inspiring

PS 27.10 Avviando un Photomerge da LRClassic con il comando "unisci come panorama in Photoshop" si apre la finestra di dialogo con i vari file da unire e le opzioni di unione ma quando si fa partire il Photomerge non accade nulla anche se la spia del processore del PC lampeggia come se stesse lavorando.

Translate

JohanElzenga

Community Expert

Known issue.

https://community.adobe.com/bug-reports-711/p-photoshop-27-10-edit-in-photoshop-from-lightroom-classic-does-not-load-image-1639250?tid=1639250&postid=7745403

Translate

-- Johan W. Elzenga

C

Cato31926727j3o6

Participant

When doing adjustment to a .NEF file in Lightroom it will not open in Photoshop when I apply Denoise in Lightroom (this used to be no problem) !

Translate

Rob_Sylvan

Community Expert

Another workaround (only for photos with Denoise applied) I’ve been using so I don’t have to rollback Ps or disable Denoise, is to use LrC’s export function to send the copy to Ps. On the Export dialog, configure the copy to be saved to the same folder as original, then check the boxes to add to catalog and add to stack. Use the same file naming convention as you use on External Editing preferences (such as -Edit), and configure the same file type, color space, and bit depth as External Editing preference in the File Settings panel. Include all metadata, no sharpening, don’t resize (but set PPI if you wish), and finally, choose to Open in Ps as the Post-Processing step. Save that as a preset for easy re-use (even from the File > Export with Preset menu to skip the dialog box). Something like this:

As long as that was the last export preformed, you can also use the shortcut for Export with Previous, which is (win) Ctrl + Alt + Shift + E / (mac) Command + Option + Shift + E

Translate